Two of the biggest names in the smoking and grilling world are Big Green Egg and Weber. You might know Big Green Egg because the company makes combination products that work as both a smoker and a grill that literally look like a big green egg. Weber offers a number of great grills as well as smokers and grill and smoker combos.
We understand that picking a combo that will help you grill and the smoke food is hard, which is why we did some of the legwork for you. Not only can you check out a list of things to look for as you shop, but you can also see which models from both companies are worth the price.
Comparing Big Green Egg vs. Weber Grills
When you decide to buy a new grill, you might head to the nearest store and grab one that looks nice without thinking about whether it will keep up with the demands of all the backyard parties and barbecues that you want to host. Our list of what to look for and how to compare models from both companies will act as a starting point to ensure that you pick the top model from either company.
In regards to cost, Weber will always win. The top grill and smoker combos from Weber cost in the $300 to $500 range. You’ll find smaller charcoal grills that cost $100 or less and larger propane grills that cost more than $500.
The cheapest option from Big Green Egg is its mini model, which is twice the price of most Weber grills. Big Green Egg refers to its grills by size and uses names like XX-Large or Mini. Those who purchased the grills in the past find that the grills are worth those high prices.
Legs and Support
Weber grills come with metal legs that snap onto the bottom and are strong enough to support both the grill and rack(s) inside as well as any food that you cook. Big Green Egg calls its legs “nests” because the pieces act like a nest to support the egg inside. The support pieces included with these models are usually stronger than those that come with Weber grills.
The handles found on Weber grills feature a material that is similar to plastic, which can reach a high temperature as you cook. Big Green Egg includes wood handles on its grills that will remain cool to the touch, even after hours of cooking. These grills often come with handles on the nests that let you move the grills while the inside or outside is still hot.
Depending on the combo that you buy, you may find that you can use more cooking methods than you expected. Weber grill combos are perfect for grilling, but you can also use some models with wood pellets or wood pieces to smoke meats. Big Green Egg grills can grill and smoke foods as well sear or bake dishes.
The 10-year warranty that Weber offers on its grills seems pretty impressive until you find out that Big Green Egg offers a lifetime warranty on its products. Keep in mind that this is a limited lifetime warranty that might not cover all types of damage. You may be responsible for paying the shipping costs to send back your grill.
Both Weber and Big Green Egg grill combos come with a temperature dial or gauge on the outside. The best thing about this dial is that it automatically changes based on the temperature inside. Keeping an eye on the temp will tell you when to turn down the heat or add more wood.
When you invest in a Big Green Egg grill, you’ll want to show it off to your friends and family, but many of its larger products are too heavy to move. If you want one that you can take to the parking or on camping trips, you should stick to the mini model. Weber grills are much more portable and generally weigh less too, making these grills best for those want to cook in their yards and away from home.
It’s hard to say which company wins when it comes to cooking size because there are so many different products available from both companies. Big Green Egg wins because its largest grill has enough space inside to cook multiple dishes or to cook enough burgers and hot dogs to feed a large crowd.
You may want to check out some of the accessories that each company makes to go along with its grills too. You’ll find pots and pans for keeping sauces warm and cooking side dishes as well as tools and equipment for cooking poultry and other special dishes.
Top Smoker and Grill Combos from Big Green Egg
1. Big Green Egg Kamado Grill MiniMax Portable Outdoor Smoker Barbecue BBQ (Check Price on Amazon.com)
The Big Green Egg Kamado Grill MiniMax Portable Outdoor Smoker Barbecue BBQ is definitely not the largest smoker available from the company, but its smaller size is one of the main reasons why it’s the best one from that company. This lightweight and compact grill are perfect for use in your backyard during a party, but you can also toss it in your car for taking on a camping trip or for tailgating outside the stadium. It really does resemble a large green egg, and that unique design keeps the hot air and smoke trapped inside.
Don’t let its small size fool you into thinking that the MiniMax is too small for your family though. It has enough cooking space inside for a turkey or chicken of up to 12 pounds, but it can also cook a whole rack of ribs, up to four hamburgers or two steaks. If you want to cook at a specific temperature, you can check the temperature inside on the dial located on the front.
Big Green Egg includes a nest that serves two purposes. This small nest attaches to the bottom of the grill and serves as a base to keep the grill from touching the ground or any surface you place it on, but the nest also has handles on each side that let you transport the grill without waiting for the outside to cool down first. Designed for grilling and smoking, this smaller grill is also perfect for making side dishes and using other cooking methods like baking for making delicious desserts.
The biggest difference between the grills and smokers that Big Green Egg makes is the size, and if you need to feed a hungry crowd and can’t cook in shifts, you need this Big Green Egg Kamado style Ceramic Grill with Nest, XX-Large, which is the largest of all the company’s grills. This XX-Large model is so big that you can cook larger chickens and turkeys inside and still have room left over for burgers and other dishes. The manufacturer designed this grill to work with all of its popular accessories, including the tables and stands that will support the egg.
Most ceramic grills come with a warranty that lasts for a few years, but Big Green Egg offers a limited lifetime warranty on this grill, which is the first time that a company offered such a long warranty on a ceramic grill. It features an adjustable temperature control that makes it easier to cook food when you’re not home. This feature lets you select the temperature that you want, let the grill cook and come back later to see the temperature still set to the degree you wanted.
A wood handle on the front of the grill is resistant to smoke and fire damage, but this handle allows you to open the lid and check on your food without burning yourself. The grate inside keeps your food close to the heat for even cooking and keeps the food from sticking to that grate. It also features a temperature dial on the outside that automatically changes as the temperature inside the grill does.
Top Smoker and Grill Combos from Weber
No matter where you want to cook, you’ll love having this Weber 721001 Smokey Mountain Cooker 22-Inch Charcoal Smoker ready and waiting for you. At 22-inches, this is the largest of all the smoker and grill combos that Weber makes, and the two cooking grates inside are adjustable and give you more than 700 square inches on which to cook. A nickel plating added to the surface of the grates keeps a grip on your food to keep those foods from sliding through but also keeps those foods from sticking to the grates.
Though Weber calls this a charcoal smoker, you can use it as a wood smoker too. The company even makes a chimney that you can purchase separately, which vents the excess smoke away from the smoker to keep foods from overcooking. The outside of the grill uses a type of heavy-duty steel with a porcelain-enamel coating on the surface that traps the heat inside.
Inside the smoker is a pan that you can fill with water, which keeps the wood from producing too much smoke and ensures that the smoke produced doesn’t overpower your food. It also comes with vents that you can open and close to change the amount of smoke inside and a heat-resistant handle on top that will stay cool, even when cooking at a high temperature. The 10-year warranty that Weber offers on this smoker covers all the included parts.
Weber also offers this grill as a part of different bundle packages. You can order a package that comes with a smoker and accessories like a thermometer or a lighter cube.
Whether you want to cook up a batch of burgers for your next get together, or you want to try out a new smoke recipe that you just found, the Weber 2820 Smokey Mountain Cooker/Smoker is great for all those jobs and many others too. This smoker uses charcoal that you place in the bottom, which then produces smoke that rises up to cover any food placed inside. It comes with two grates that measure just over 18-inches across that have open spaces on the bottom to ensure that the smoke penetrates into all areas of the meat.
Though you’ll likely use this smoker for meats, you can also use it for poultry, seafood and even vegetables and desserts. Weber recommends removing one of the grates to increase the cooking space inside for making ribs, smoking poultry and cooking larger dishes. As the smoker is 41-inches tall, you’ll find that you can check on your food and even turn or rearrange that food without bending or leaning over the smoker.
The cooking space inside this smoker is so large that Weber claims you can cook both a ham and a small turkey inside at the same time, which might make feeding your family on the holidays easier. Each of the two cooking grates has a nickel plating that keeps food from burning or sticking to the metal during longer smoking periods. This steel smoker, which has a 10-year warranty from Weber, has a porcelain-enamel coating on the outside that won’t fade, and this material is resistant to corrosion caused by water and moisture too.
Big Green Egg vs. Weber: Who Wins?
In a direct battle between Big Green Egg and Weber, it’s hard to tell who really comes out on top. The grills from Big Green Egg are quite impressive and will wow anyone who comes over. There are a number of accessories available too for cooking special dishes on your grill, which gives Big Green Egg a slight advantage over Weber.
Weber has a great reputation online and a good history of helping its customers. The grill and smoker combos that it makes are more affordable and have lots of room for cooking too. To pick the best product for you, the low prices of Weber products may be the deciding factor.