We hope you love the products we recommend. SeriouslySmoked.com may earn a commission on qualifying purchases from Amazon Associates or other vendors. Read more here.
Our Top Choice...
What started in Italy has become a worldwide phenomenon: The humble pizza.
Adored by adults and children alike for its perfect combination of crispy crust, gooey cheese, and savory toppings, pizza is a staple in households across the world.
In fact, 93 percent of Americans have eaten pizza in the last month — and altogether, the U.S. will eat approximately 100 acres of pizza a day. That’s almost 350 slices per second!
If you’re itching to make your own pizzas at home, take heart: There are plenty of options for kitchen equipment that will make professional-quality pizzas. Once you’ve decided on which of our 7 best indoor pizza ovens is right for your home and your budget, you’ll never have to order takeout pizza again!
With our years of experience in Italian kitchens and as home cooks, we’ve put together this list of reviews for the best indoor pizza ovens around. By the time you’re done reading, you’ll know exactly which pizza oven is the best for your personal kitchen situation.
Let’s get started!
Here are the best indoor pizza oven and pizza makers you can buy:
- Best Overall - Nostalgia Large Capacity Retro Toaster Oven
- Runner Up - Presto Pizzazz Plus Rotating Oven
- Premium Choice - Oster French Door Toaster Oven
- Most Versatile - Cuisinart TOA-60 Convection Toaster Oven Airfryer
- Fastest Baking Times - Wisco 421 LED Display Pizza Oven
- Easiest to Clean - Betty Crocker BC-2958CR Pizza Maker
- Best Value Convection - Luby Large Countertop French Door Toaster Oven
For the complete product list, please continue reading...
Top 7 Indoor Pizza Makers (2021 Reviews)
1. Best Overall - Nostalgia Large Capacity Retro Toaster Oven
Huge baking capacity at a reasonable price
Versatile cooking options make it great for more than just pizza
Comes with a built-in timer for easy and precise cooking
Removable interior components make it extremely easy to clean
Fast preheating and high maximum temperature
Stylish retro design will look great on your countertop
Wire racks are fairly thin, and have trouble holding heavy baking pans
- 0.7 cubic foot baking capacity
- Fits up to two 12-inch pizzas
- Bake, toast, convection bake, and broil settings
- Adjustable temperature from 200 to 450 degrees F
- Built-in timer
- Clear-view window and stainless steel handle on door
- Baking pan, wire racks, and crumb tray are removable
- Measures 18.50 x 15.50 x 11.50 inches
It’s not every day that you find a piece of kitchen equipment that is just as good looking as it is functional — but that’s exactly what the Nostalgia Retro Toaster Oven offers. Large enough to fit two 12-inch pizzas, it’s a unit that preheats quickly and can be adjusted easily with the manual knobs on its well-designed face.
The first thing you’ll notice about the Nostalgia is its chic, all-red, retro styling. Designed to fit in with any aesthetic from the 50s and onward, it’s blessedly well-equipped with bake, toast, convection, and broil settings. This, in combination with its built-in timer and clear window for easy viewing make it a versatile piece of equipment for any kitchen.
Even lacking an auto shut-off feature, we think the Nostalgia Retro Toaster Oven is unbelievably useful given its reasonable price. As long as you have the countertop space, it’s hard to imagine a reason not to use this as your go to pizza oven.
2. Runner up - Presto Pizzazz Plus Rotating Oven
Lightweight and inexpensive
Takes up very little countertop space
Adjustable heating elements can be used for fresh and frozen pizzas
Auto shut-off with built-in timer prevents your pizzas from getting burnt
Only accommodates pizzas up to 12 inches
Takes a long time to preheat and cook
- Cooks pizzas from 7 to 12 inches
- Top and bottom heating elements with separate controls
- Rotating tray
- Integrated timer with auto shut-off
- Removable non-stick baking pan
- Measures 15.8 x 14.5 x 10.3 inches
Offering the ability to make frozen or fresh pizzas anywhere from 7 to 12 inches at an exceptionally low cost, the Presto Pizzazz Plus Rotating Oven focuses on pizzas rather than trying to do it all. As a budget-friendly option for hungry pizza lovers, it definitely does the trick — and if you’re looking to save space on your countertop, look no further than the Pizzazz.
With top and bottom heating elements for precise crispness control, this pizza maker from Presto can bake pizzas nearly to restaurant quality (but it will take a while to do so). The rotating tray moves independently, leading to evenly toasted pizza without any hassle.
We really appreciate the timer and auto shut-off on this rotating pizza oven, as well as the easy to clean non-stick baking tray. Get this pizza oven if you’re short on cash or countertop space, and you’ll be quite pleased.
3. Premium Choice - Oster French Door Toaster Oven
Largest pizza baking capacity of any oven in our review
Effortless opening French doors are safe and easy to use
Foolproof digital controls
Built-in timer with auto shut-off prevents burnt pizzas
Durable stainless steel construction
Easy to clean thanks to removable interior components
Large size may not be right for all countertops
- Large enough to bake up to two 16-inch pizzas
- French doors open with a one-handed pull
- Digital controls for toast, bake, broil, and pizza settings
- Removable crumb tray, baking pan, and two racks
- 90-minute timer with integrated auto shut-off
- Turbo Convection for fast preheating
- Stainless steel construction
- Measures 21.60 x 19.20 x 12.90 inches
French door convection ovens are the baking tool of choice for many professional kitchens. With the Oster French Door Toaster Oven, you can bring that restaurant-quality power and service into your own home — albeit in a miniaturized version.
Boasting the largest baking capacity of any pizza oven in our review, this Oster convection oven is pricey but not overpriced. With enough space to bake two 16-inch pizzas (with a little bit of room to spare), and Oster’s “Turbo Convection” system for ultra-fast preheating, this is definitely the fastest and most efficient oven in our review, too.
Truly, this multi-function toaster oven is nearly large enough to replace a traditional oven. In short, if you want the best of the best for your pizzas, this oven should be your top choice.
4. Most Versatile - Cuisinart TOA-60 Convection Toaster Oven Airfryer
Provides many more cooking options than just baking pizzas
Powerful 1800 Watt electric cooking preheats quickly and has adjustable temperature
Integrated timer with auto shut-off prevents pizza burning
Small countertop footprint is great for saving space in small kitchens
Harder to clean than many other pizza ovens
Fairly small baking capacity
- 0.6 cubic foot interior
- Large enough for a single 12-inch pizza, 6 slices of bread, 3 pounds of chicken wings, or a 4 pound chicken
- 1800 Watt power source
- Seven functions: Air fry, convection bake, convection broil, bake, broil, toast, and keep warm
- Built-in 60 minute timer with auto shut-off
- Removable oven rack, baking pan, and air fryer basket
- Measures 15.50 x 16.00 x 14.00 inches
Air fryers are all the rage. One of the latest in a long line of kitchen gadgets, Cuisinart’s TOA-60 combines multiple functions into one compact, powerful machine that’s great for saving space in smaller kitchens. Its 12-inch pizza capacity is nothing to write home about, but a host of other baking, frying, and toasting functions make it more versatile than any other pizza oven on our list.
Even better, the TOA-60 is quite easy to clean as well. It’s equipped with a removable oven rack, baking pan, crumb sheet, and air fryer basket that are all dishwasher safe. Overall, this oven from Cuisinart is an excellent choice for anyone looking to take advantage of the latest advancements in kitchen technology. It provides you all the cooking items you’ll need.
5. Fastest Baking Times - Wisco 421 LED Display Pizza Oven
Professional quality pizza oven cooks faster than any other in our review
One-touch pizza baking makes it fast and easy to pop in a frozen pizza
Highest temperature potential of any oven we tested
Easy to clean thanks to a removable crumb tray
Only fits one pizza
Lacks the versatility of other ovens we tested
- Fits up to a 14-inch pizza
- One-touch pizza bake setting at 450 degrees F for 10 minutes
- Removable crumb tray
- Adjustable thermostat from 150 to 500 degrees F
- Calrod heating elements
- 1500 Watt, 12.5 Amp power source
- Measures 18 x 15 x 7.75 inches
The choice of to-go pizza restaurants around the US, Wisco’s LED display pizza oven is a hyper-specialized piece of kitchen equipment that makes baking pizzas blazing fast. You can see this most clearly in its one-touch setting, which bakes a single pizza at 450 degrees for 10 minutes. For ease of use and professional quality results, we give the Wisco 421 a big thumb up.
Offering the fastest baking times of any oven we tested, the Wisco does one thing and one thing only: bake pizzas! If you have plenty of space on your countertops to dedicate to baking perfect pizzas, it’s an excellent (if somewhat pricey) option.
6. Easiest to Clean - Betty Crocker BC-2958CR Pizza Maker
Nonstick baking plates are extremely fast and easy to clean
Useful for more than just pizzas
Very energy efficient, and won’t heat up a whole room
Durable stainless steel construction
Long preheating times
Doesn’t give a very crisp crust
- Bakes up to a 12-inch pizza
- Energy efficient design
- Nonstick coated baking plates
- Stainless steel construction
- Can also be used for quesadillas, quiche, giant cookies, and more
- 1440 Watts power source
- Measures 13.78 x 15.87 x 5.04 inches
Featuring perhaps the oddest design of any pizza maker in our reviews, Betty Crocker’s BC-2958CR is just as useful for making quesadillas or giant cookies as it is pizza. Featuring a double-sided baking pan design, it’s an energy-efficient way to quickly bake a pizza without having to heat up the whole house.
Made of heavyweight stainless steel, this pizza maker takes up quite a bit of counter space given its moderate versatility. It’s the most reasonably priced pizza maker of any we tested, and is exceptionally easy to clean thanks to durable non-stick coating on both baking trays.
7. Best Value Convection Pizza Oven - Luby Large Countertop French Door Toaster Oven
Extra large baking capacity is useful for much more than just pizzas
Space-saving French doors open with one handed operation
Variable temperature controls allow you to cook two different foods at the same time
Automatic shut-off and built-in timer prevent burnt food
Large size takes up a lot of counter space
Takes a long time to preheat
- Large enough to bake two 14-inch pizzas, roast a 20 pound turkey, or bake 24 muffins
- French doors with single-handle opening
- Precise temperature control for upper and lower racks
- Integrated 60-minute timer with auto shut-off
- Measures 22.04 x 16.14 x 14.37 inches
Last but not least, the Luby Countertop French Door Toaster Oven offers many of the benefits of the convection ovens that took our top picks, all at a fraction of the price. If you liked the looks and performance of brands like Cuisinart listed above, but can’t stomach the price, the Luby is a perfect alternative.
While it can take quite a while to preheat, we appreciate the Luby’s large baking capacity. It takes up quite a bit of counter space, but can be used as a replacement for an oven in smaller studio apartments where you may not have one in your kitchen.
A nearly perfect combination of style and substance, the Nostalgia Large Capacity Retro Toaster Oven easily takes our top pick as the best indoor pizza oven for the money. It’s well-equipped for personal use or making multiple pies for a family, available for a great price, and provides consistently delicious results thanks to its convection heating. There’s no other pizza maker we’d rather have in our homes.
Anyone on a tighter budget would do well to equip themselves with a Presto Pizzazz Plus Rotating Oven, though. While it’s not going to provide the same restaurant-quality results as our top pick, it’s infinitely better (and less expensive) than using your home oven. If your budget can’t stretch to accommodate a convection oven, this pizza maker is the next best thing.
How to Choose the Best Indoor Pizza Oven
If you’ve ever made a pizza in your standard home oven, you may have noticed that the results are significantly different from what you find in restaurants. What gives?
Getting a perfectly crispy crust and melted cheese takes a little bit more know-how, and better heating than your large oven is likely capable of. Read on to discover the keys to making a restaurant-quality pizza in your own home:
What to Look for In An Indoor Pizza Oven
In every pizza maker that we’ve tested, three characteristics set apart the best ovens from ones that were just okay — or even downright bad. These are what you’ll want to take into consideration as you look for the perfect pizza oven for your kitchen:
- Size plays a huge factor in deciding on which indoor pizza oven is best for you, and is the main difference between styles of pizza makers. Look for one that will fit comfortably on your countertop, and then choose the oven with the largest capacity that your budget can afford.
- Type of Heating will determine exactly how crispy and perfectly cooked your pizzas will be. Convection ovens are our favorites, but are always on the more expensive side. Plate baking options are much more affordable, but won’t give quite as toasted of a crust.
- Power shows in both the pre-heating and maximum working temperatures for your oven, and will determine how quickly you can bake your pizza. If you can afford a more powerful oven, it will save you plenty of time at dinner.
- Easy Cleanup isn’t absolutely necessary, but it will make your life much easier after the meal. Look for pizza makers with non-stick plates, or pull-out crumb trays.
Types of Pizza Makers
Pizza makers for your indoor kitchen come in three main varieties:
- Convection Ovens circulate hot air with a fan, allowing for even cooking temperatures across the whole interior of the oven. They’re better than conventional thermal ovens at producing consistent results, and will preheat much faster and use less energy overall.
- Rotating pizza makers have a heating element above and below a rotating plate, and use intense heat to cook the pizza evenly as it spins. They take a bit longer to achieve truly crispy results, but are often much less expensive.
- Press pizza makers double as quesadilla makers or giant cookie presses, and use two heated plates to cook your food. They’re similar to a waffle iron, but without the ridges.
Try to see also our review for Camp Chef Pizza Oven for camping enthusiasts and Countertop Pizza Ovens that you can easily use and put in a kitchen table.