The 9 Best Muffin Pans For Easy Baking

    Last Updated on

    OUR TOP CHOICE

    OUR TOP CHOICE

    Key Features

     The non-stick is excellent

     Great heat and cooking distribution

     Perfect for larger muffins

      Dishwasher safe

     Durable steel construction

      Limited 5-year warranty

    Our pick for the best muffin pan is the Wilton Recipe Right Muffin Pan. It is a perfect muffin pan for most baking needs. It heats fairly evenly, and muffin tops come out nicely browned and just slightly crispy. It does a great job with other foods too, so it was an easy pick for the best muffin pan.


    BakewareMuffin pans, they aren’t just for muffins anymore. There are so many things you can use a muffin pan for. Yes, muffins are obvious, but search the internet and you’ll find creative chefs using muffin pans to create mini quiche, breakfast “sandwiches”, single serving appetizers, and of course, cupcakes.  The muffin pan is truly a versatile kitchen tool. 

    Knowing this, you should run out and buy a muffin pan. But make sure it’s the right muffin pan. Believe it or not, different types of muffin pans will impact the quality of your muffin or whatever you’re cooking. Once upon a time, the only option was your basic aluminum muffin pan. 

    Today, there are muffin pans in a variety of materials, with a variety of coatings, and in a variety of sizes. Knowing what you want to cook in your muffin pan may determine which you buy. It is important to know which materials are best for even cooking batters, which will brown and crisp the best, and which are best suited for cupcakes. Because, cupcakes are different, and you may want to select a pan just for them.

    So, how do you go about picking the right muffin pan? Well, if you pop on to any number of websites selling kitchenware, or stop into your local big box store, you’re going to be overwhelmed with the options. There are pans in every shape, size and arrangement, and picking one, can feel like more work than muffins are worth.

    Don’t worry, we’re here to help. In this review, we’ve compiled the best muffin pans on the market today. We’ve baked and baked and baked to find the right pans, with a variety of options, designed to make great muffins, cupcakes, breakfast sandwiches or anything else you can bake in a muffin pan. To help you make the best choice for you, we’ve also put together a buying guide, with all of the essential features you should consider when shopping for a muffin pan.


    Here are the best muffin pans you can buy:

    For the complete product list, please continue reading…


    Top 9 Best Muffin Pans (2020 Reviews)

    1. Best Overall – Wilton Recipe Right Muffin Pan

    Pros:

    Heavy duty material
    Value to price ratio
    Browns muffins perfectly
    Limited 5-year warranty Good warranty

    Cons:

    Smaller side handles

    Specifications:

      • Size: 12 cup
      • Material: Steel
      • Dimensions: 14.55 x 10.5 x 1.3 inches
      • Weight: 1.14 pounds

    The Wilton Right Results non-stick muffin pan is both basic and affordable. It is also a great product. Wilton has been making quality steel bakeware since 1929, so you know when you buy this muffin pan, you’re getting a product from a company that has stood the test of time.

    We like the extra wide edges of these pans, which make them easy to handle, even when you’re wearing pot holders. We also liked that extra room because it kept our fingers and our hot mitts out of muffin batter or scrambled eggs. The non-stick coating is great, and we found that it continued to be effective after a number of uses, which is where some other pans failed. 

    This product also wins in the convenience category. All of the Wilton products are dishwasher safe, because no one really likes to do dishes. They do recommend washing their products by hand with warm soapy water before and after the first use, otherwise, don’t be afraid to toss these in the dishwasher.

    Wrapping up

    When it comes to bakeware that is both affordable and works great, you can’t go wrong with Wilton. Their muffin pan is no exception, and for the price, you just can’t get a better product.


    2. Runner up – Chicago Metallic Non-stick Giant Professional Coating Muffin Pan

    Pros:

    Generous portions
    Comes in various sizes
    Very durable material
    Endless versatility

    Cons:

    Hand wash recommended
    Higher priced

    Specifications:

      • Size: 6 Cup
      • Material: Heavy-duty carbon steel
      • Dimensions: 2’’ H x 13.8’’ L x 10.5’’ W
      • Weight: 1.15 lb.

    This fun pan gives you the opportunity to make your own giant muffins. Our pick for the runner up best muffin pan is the Chicago Metallic non-stick giant muffin pan.

    This six cup muffin pan makes those extra big muffins that you usually find at coffee shops or bakeries. Now you can make them at home, and with the Chicago Metallic pan, it’s really easy. The Chicago Metallic baking ware features a non-stick coating that is dishwasher safe, for easy clean up. The larger cup size also allows you to make dishes like individual quiche or even full-size breakfast sandwiches. 

    Our one complaint about these pans is the narrow edges that are a bit tricky to handle when you’re wearing hot mitts. This isn’t a deal breaker, but we do wish that there was a bit more room to hold on to the pan.


    3. Best Non-Stick – Circulon Bakeware Nonstick Muffin Tin

    Pros:

    PFOA-free
    Heavy duty material yet light
    The wide handles
    A hassle-free lifetime guarantee

    Cons:

    Only oven safe to 450 degrees F
    Hand wash recommended

    Specifications:

      • Size: 12 cup
      • Material: Heavy gauge steel
      • Dimensions: 15.5 x 10.5 x 1.25 inches
      • Weight: 1.2 pounds

    This muffin pan is our pick for the best non-stick pan, for good reason. We really like the heavy-duty steel construction of this muffin pan from Circulon. The rolled edges of the pan and handles make this pan easy to hold, and move around, even when wearing oven mitts.

    Circulon is known for their non-stick bakeware. Their products are well made, and are intended to last a long time. The non-stick coating is POFA free, so if you’re concerned about chemicals from your cookware, this is a great option. The ridged bottoms of the muffin cups help muffins slide out of the pan easier.

    This pan is a bit on the darker side, so be aware that your muffins and cupcakes will brown a bit darker than with some other pans. All Circulon products are dishwasher safe, so clean up is quick and easy.


    4. Best Design – USA Pan (1200MF) Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin Pan

    Pros:

    Very versatile
    Durable, high-performance design
    PTFE, PFOA and BPA free
    Non-stick is awesome

    Cons:

    Not dishwasher safe

    Specifications:

      • Size: 12 cup
      • Material: Aluminized steel
      • Dimensions: 15.75 x 1.3 x 1.33 inches
      • Weight: 1.9 pounds

    USA Pan Bakeware is another one of those companies that has been making quality bakeware for a long time. USA Pan has been a favorite of professional bakers and is frequently the choice for baking equipment in bakeries and restaurants.

    Their bakeware products for home use are made with the same high quality aluminized steel, which increases the life of the pans, and makes for even cooking. The USA Pan muffin pan features corrugated surfaces to improve the non-stick functionality of the pan. This muffin pan is coated with a thin layer of silicone, which makes it non-stick and free of worrisome chemicals that may be present in some other non-stick coatings. The lighter color of these pans mean a lighter brown baking result which is great for cupcakes and rolls.

    Besides being highly functional, these pans look great, so they can easily go from your oven, straight to your breakfast table. Our one complaint about this muffin pan is that it isn’t dishwasher safe. However, the non-stick coating makes it super easy to wash down with soap and water, so this isn’t too big of an issue, in our mind.

    This is kind of the average knife in a lot of ways. Good steel but not the best, long but not exceptionally so, nice looking but not decorative, and pricey but not overly expensive. Ultimately that’s why it just barely edges out the best spot. Not because it’s necessarily the highest quality knife here, but because it’s the best and most expensive I would expect the average person to be comfortable buying. Unless you’re a professional chef or just really love knives, this is the best you’ll probably feel a need to get.


    5. Best Commercial – Nordic Ware Natural Muffin Pan with Lid

    Pros:

    The Lid
    Can go in fridge or freezer
    PTFE Free and PFOA Free
    Creates even heat distribution

    Cons:

    Not non-stick
    Recommended hand wash

    Specifications:

      • Size: 12 Cup
      • Material: Aluminum
      • Dimensions: 2.125” H x 13.5” L x 9.25” W
      • Weight: 1.6 lb.

    If you want to use a more professional style muffin pan in your kitchen, then we would suggest the Nordic Ware muffin pan.

    This pan is pretty simple, but it does a great job of cooking muffins, cupcakes and other goodies. Its aluminum construction provides even heating across the pan, so even cupcakes or muffins in the center of the pan are cooked perfectly. The light color of this muffin pan is great for lightly browned cupcakes or rolls.

    This pan is not non-stick, so if you are baking without using paper muffin cups, you’ll want to use cooking spray before you fill the cups. We do like that this muffin pan comes with a lid. This is a great option for taking cupcakes or other treats to parties or for storing in the fridge or freezer.


    6. Best Versatility – Anolon Advanced Muffin Pan

    Pros:

    Cool bronze color
    Even heat distribution
    Rubberized handles
    Limited lifetime warranty

    Cons:

    Oven safe to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
    On the heavier side

    Specifications:

      • Size: 12 Cup
      • Material: Heavy gauge carbon steel
      • Dimensions: 1.5’’ H x 11.75’’ L x 16.25’’ W
      • Weight: 2.2 lb.

    This muffin pan from Anolon is our pick for the most versatile pan, thanks to its carbon steel construction. This beautiful bronze colored pan looks great, and does a great job of even cooking a variety of foods.

    The carbon steel construction is non-stick naturally, so there is no worry about chemicals that may be present in other non-stick coatings. The lighter color of this pan creates even heat distribution for light, golden-brown muffins, rolls and cupcakes.

    This pan is a bit bigger, so it’s great for making mini-quiche or mini-pot pies. The carbon steel construction allows you to slide these foods from the pan, with little to no effort.

    We like the rubberized handles for easy transport. But this pan is not dishwasher safe, so you’ll have to hand wash to maintain the seasoning of the pan.


    7. Best Handles – Rachael Ray Yum-O Non-Stick Muffin Pan

    Pros:

    Oven safe to 500°F
    Nonstick inside and out
    Extra-wide handles with comfortable silicone grips
    Dishwasher Safe

    Cons:

    Cups are a little shallow

    Specifications:

      • Size: 12-Cup
      • Material: Steel
      • Dimensions: 1.5’’ H x 15.5’’ L x 10.5’’ W
      • Weight: 1.5 lb.

    If you’re going to be cooking with your kids, or if you just like to have a pan that is easy to hang on to, then the muffin pan for you is the Rachael Ray Yum-O muffin pan.

    This pan features steel construction with a durable non-stick coating. It cooks evenly, and results in a darker browning than lighter pans. The wide edges, and easy to hold, silicone handles, make moving this pan from the oven to your cooling rack safe and stable.

    This pan is dishwasher safe, so clean up is easy. Though we did find that this pan’s non-stick coating did most of the clean-up work for us.


    8. Best 6 Cup – Geraldine Muffin Pan

     

    Geraldine 6 Cup

     

    Pros:

    It’s a 2 pack
    Perfect if you only need 6 muffins
    Good portion sizes
    Easy to clean

    Cons:

    Heavy for its size
    Not ad long lasting as some

    Specifications:

      • Size: (2) 6 cups
      • Material: Steel
      • Dimensions: 0.6” H x 13” L x 9” W
      • Weight: 3lbs. (1.5 lb. ea.)

    Sometimes, you just don’t want or need to make 12 muffins or cupcakes. If you’re baking for one or two people, 6 muffins are sometimes more than enough. Our pick for the best 6 cup muffin pan is the two pack of muffin pans from Geraldine.

    These pans are non-stick and feature a darker gray surface. Steel construction provides even heating, but we did find that this pan cooked a bit slower than others. You’ll need to watch your baking with this pan, because we also found that it browned muffins pretty quick at the end of the cook time.

    This is not a giant muffin pan, so you’ll get just regular sized muffins or cupcakes from this pan. The two pack gives you the versatility of making 6 or 12 muffins.


    9. Best Budget – Cuisinox Non-Stick Muffin/Cupcake Pan

    Cuisinox

    Pros:

    Budget price
    PTFE Free and PFOA Free
    Oven safe to 500°F
    Dishwasher safe

    Cons:

    Muffins stick a little bit
    Wells are on the small side

    Specifications:

      • Size: 12 Cup
      • Material: Aluminum
      • Dimensions: 1’’ H x 13.5’’ L x 10.5’’ W
      • Weight: 1.2 lb.

    If you just want a basic muffin pan, then this is your pick. The Cuisinox muffin pan is just about as simple as you can get, but still does a great job of baking a variety of foods.

    This pan features light-weight aluminum construction, so it is easy to handle. The aluminum construction allows for even heating across the pan. It is a bit on the dark side, so your baked goods will brown a bit more than with some other pans. 

    The non-stick coating on this pan makes clean up easy, and the pan is dishwasher safe, so no hand washing required.


    Final Verdict

    Wilton Recipe RightCheck Price on Amazon

    Check Price on Walmart

    Our pick for the best muffin pan, the Wilton Recipe Right Muffin Pan, is a versatile option that allows you to easily cook everything from eggs to your favorite cupcakes. It cooks fairly evenly, and we found that it was easy to care for.

    No kitchen should be without a muffin pan. It is an incredibly useful, and versatile piece of cookware. Besides, without a muffin pan, you can’t make cupcakes, and who doesn’t love a cupcake?


    How to Choose the Best Muffin Pan

    Choosing a muffin pan can be a bit daunting. There are tons and tons of options. To help you pick the right pan for your needs, we’ve put together this list of features that you should consider when shopping for a muffin pan. The features on this list were those that we considered when we were making our list, so they are great for you to use as well.

    SIZE

    There are a couple of size factors that you’ll need to consider when shopping for a muffin pan. First, you should consider the number of muffins that your pan can make at one time. Some pans make six muffins, some make 18. Just remember that when it comes to standard sized muffins, the more that your pan makes, the bigger the pan. You’ll need to make sure you have room to store a larger pan and that your oven is large enough to hold a large muffin pan.

    The next size factor is the cup size of your muffin pan. Do you love giant muffins in the morning? There’s a pan for that. Are you looking to make mini-muffins or cupcakes? There’s a pan for that. Do you just love the top of the muffin? There’s a shallow muffin pan just for those too. Muffin cups come in a variety of sizes, so make sure you pick the one that best suits your needs.

    MATERIALS

    Material is probably one of the most important factors when it comes to selecting a muffin pan. There are a few different materials that muffin pans are made from, and each has its pros and cons. 

    • Stainless Steel: We are fans of stainless steel. For muffin pans, stainless steel is a good option. It’s durable and easy to clean. Most come with a non-stick coating which makes removing your muffins easy. Stainless steel conducts heat slower, so you may find that your muffins or cupcakes don’t cook as fast as the mix or recipe suggests.
    • Aluminum: Aluminum is probably the most popular material for muffin pans. It is lightweight and conducts heat evenly and at a more rapid pace. Most aluminum muffin pans also come with a non-stick coating.
    • Steel: Old school muffin pans were made from steel, and they are great. The versions you can buy today are also awesome, and come with the handy non-stick coating. Steel muffin pans can be heavy, but they are also super durable.
    • Carbon Steel: Similar to cast iron, carbon steel is naturally non-stick, when properly seasoned, so if you want to avoid non-stick coatings this is the pick for you. Carbon steel is also lighter weight than cast iron or regular steel, so it’s not a huge chore to move around.
    • Silicone: Silicone is quickly becoming popular for all sorts of cookware. It handles high heat well, and is flexible. Silicone muffin pans are non-stick and your muffins just pop out. However, silicone doesn’t heat very evenly, so you may find that your muffins cook differently across the pan.

    COATING

    Many muffin pans come with a PTFE, non-stick coating. This coating is better known as Teflon. This coating works great at keeping foods from sticking to surfaces. There was some concern a few years back about the safety of Teflon in cookware. Since that time, there have been advances in the product, and if you purchase new Teflon coated cookware, you can be confident that the product is safe. Just make sure that you care for your Teflon coated cookware, even muffin pans, according to the manufacturer’s suggestion to keep the coating in good condition, and free from scratches that alter the coating’s effectiveness.

    COLOR

    You might be surprised to know that the way your muffins turn out is directly related to the color of your muffin pan. Darker pans tend to brown muffins more. Light colored pans create more pale muffins. A pan in the middle creates a result somewhere in between light and dark. 

    Browning is not the only way that the color of your muffin pan can influence the way your muffins cook. Darker pans tend to cook the edges of the batter faster, so the batter in the center rises up, creating tall muffins, and more muffin top. Lighter pans cook slower and this results in a more uniform result. Lighter pans are great for cupcakes, for this reason.

    USAGE AND CARING 

    When you are selecting a muffin pan, make sure you know what the care and maintenance requirements are, before you buy. For instance, Teflon coated pans should only be used with wood, silicone or other soft utensils. Cast iron and carbon steel pans are super durable, and don’t have that non-stick coating to worry about, but you can’t put them in the dishwasher, or you’ll ruin the seasoning, that makes them non-stick.

    If you want a pan that is easy to use, cleans up quickly, select one that is dishwasher safe, and be aware of the non-stick coating it has, so you know how to care for it.