We hope you love the products we recommend. SeriouslySmoked.com may earn a commission on qualifying purchases from Amazon Associates or other vendors. Read more here.
The last time you tried to make a pizza at home, how did it turn out?
If you’re in pursuit of restaurant-quality pizza at home, there are a lot of variables to consider. Is your oven up to the task? Have you invested in a high-quality pizza stone to add that final crisp to the crust? How’s your dough recipe?
And while these and many other considerations can make or break your pizza game, there’s nothing more frustrating than getting everything else on point — and then realizing that you have no good way to get your pizza out of the oven without ruining it!
Of course, a traditional pizza peel is the answer to many of your at-home pizza making woes. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll be sharing our years of pizza-making experience with you as we introduce you to the process behind choosing the right pizza peel for your needs.
Read on to learn more about the different types of pizza peels available to you, as well as our top picks in each of 7 categories.
Our Top Choice...
For the complete product list, please continue reading...
Top 7 Best Pizza Peels (2021 Reviews)
1. Best Overall - Checkered Chef Extra Large Pizza Peel
Extra large paddle size is suitable for even the largest of pizzas
All metal construction is ultra durable and long-lasting
Extendable handle saves space when not in use, and gets you far away from the heat while in action
Completely dishwasher safe and extremely easy to clean
Padded rubber handle makes it comfortable to use
Super thin metal head makes it easy to scoop up tricky pizzas
On the heavy side
- Paddle measures 13 x 16 inches
- Stainless steel construction
- Measures 25.5 inches long with handle fully extended
- Comfort grip rubber handle
- Dishwasher safe
- Weighs 2.8 pounds
Making pizzas, even in your home oven, can be a hot and grueling job. That’s why we think that, to secure our top recommendation, a pizza peel needs to be up to the task of taking care of ultra-hot, heavy-duty work. And thanks to a durable stainless steel construction, the Checkered Chef Extra Large Pizza Peel is definitely fit for the task.
With the handle fully extended, this pizza peel measures a whopping 25.5 inches long, with a 13 x 16 paddle that can handle even the largest of pies. Even though it’s made of solid stainless steel, the comfortable rubber handle makes it easier to use than most comparably-sized peels.
After folding the handle back in, this Checkered Chef pizza peel is compact and easy to store — and, better yet, it can actually fold down to a size that allows it to fit in your dishwasher. Of all the pizza peels we tested, only this one offers the best of all worlds. Highly recommended for just about anyone.
2. Best Value - New Star Foodservice 50301 Wooden Pizza Peel
Natural birchwood construction looks great and is eco-friendly
Generously sized head can accommodate a 16-inch pizza
Tapered blade and long handle make it easy to maneuver pizzas
Affordable yet durable
Lightweight and easy to use
Wooden construction makes it much more difficult and time-consuming to clean
Requires regular maintenance to keep the wood looking great
- Paddle measures 14 x 16 inches
- Solid birchwood construction
- Wide, tapered blade
- 30 inches long with handle
- Easy grip ergonomic handle
- Weighs 1.8 pounds
Old-school pizza peels were all made of wood, before the advent of cheap and reliable steel manufacturing. Hark back to Italian traditions with the New Star Foodservice Wood Pizza Peel, and you’ll feel like you’re in old Napoli, without a doubt. And with a price that’s only a fraction of most other peels we reviewed, the New Star is an extremely affordable alternative to metal.
We love the solid birchwood construction for this peel, since it’s both eco-friendly and quite durable. Keep in mind that you’ll need to give it a lot of love to keep it in great condition, though. As long as you don’t mind hand washing this peel, it’s built to last forever.
Measuring in at 16 inches wide and 30 inches long with the handle, this peel is more than capable of handling pizzas of any size. Lighter than any metal peel, it may appeal to paisanos with wrist or shoulder pain, too.
3. Premium Choice - Pizza Royale Ethically Sourced Premium Natural Bamboo Pizza Peel
100% bamboo construction is eco-friendly, durable, and attractive
Features a tapered blade for easy scooping
Stylish design looks great when hung on the walls of your kitchen
Lowest maintenance of any wooden pizza peel
On the small side
Hand wash only
- Paddle measures 19.6 x 12 inches
- Natural bamboo construction
- Easy grip handle with notch for hanging
- Tapered blade
- Hand wash only
- 180 day money-back guarantee
One look at the Pizza Royale Premium Natural Bamboo Pizza Peel lets you know that you’re not working with a down-and-dirty kitchen tool, but a piece of servingware in its own right. If you’ve been looking for a peel that will look as good on your table as it does tossing pizzas, only the Pizza Royale will do the trick.
Made from ethically harvested bamboo, the Pizza Royale requires relatively little maintenance for a wooden peel. The tapered blade and easy grip handle combine with a naturally lightweight construction to allow for quick maneuvering, but it’s somewhat hampered by a small blade size.
Still on the fence about this one? You can safely try it out for up to six months, thanks to the company’s 180-day money back guarantee — though we have a good feeling that you’ll be inclined towards keeping it after seeing how great it looks in your kitchen.
4. Best Design - Bertello Pizza Peel
Specifically designed to get rid of excess flour on the bottom of your pizzas
Handle folds away for space-saving storage
Thin stainless steel blade makes it easy to handle and maneuver pizzas
Perforations make it lightweight and easy to use
Hand wash only
On the small side
- Paddle measures 14.6 x 12.7 inches
- Perforated design allows excess flour and cornmeal to slide away
- Folding wooden handle
- Thin stainless steel blade
- Hand wash only
Any kitchen product that’s been featured on Shark Tank has to be worth a second look, right? And while we’ve seen plenty of ridiculous inventions cross that show, the Bertello Pizza Peel is actually an innovatively designed pizza peel that can easily deserve a place in your kitchen.
By incorporating multiple perforations into a thin stainless steel blade, the Bertello allows for any excess cornmeal and flour to fall away from your pizza before serving — making for a better-tasting, better-looking final product than you’ll get with other peels. We’re big fans of the fold-away handle, too, which makes it compact and easy to store when not in use.
If it were just a bit larger, the Bertello might have ended up securing our top pick. As it stands, the 12.7 inch wide paddle is smaller than we’d like it to be, making it difficult to handle a large (16 inch) pizza safely and effectively.
5. Best Space Saver - Chef Pomodoro Aluminum Metal Pizza Peel with Foldable Wood Handle
Compact and space saving design features a secure and easy to use handle locking mechanism
Lifted safety backstep prevents any pizza scooping mishaps
Lightweight and easy to use
Thin metal blade makes for easy pizza maneuvering
Hand wash only
On the small side
- Paddle measures 12 x 14 inches
- Made of commercial-grade aluminum and natural pine wood
- 25 inches long when fully extended
- Weighs 1.76 pounds
- Fold-out handle with screw-down locking mechanism
- Safety backstep
Small and lightweight, Mario Batali’s addition to the pizza peel world comes in the form of Chef Pomodoro — a perfect addition to any at-home pizza making endeavor, where saving space is more important than making gigantic pizzas.
Measuring 25 inches long at full extension, the Chef Pomodoro isn’t lacking in length. Folded down, however, it measures a tiny 14 x 12 inches. That makes it small enough to store in most vertical cabinets, and an excellent way to up your home oven pizza game.
Alas, with all good things must come the bad, too. In the case of this pizza peel, the pine wood handle means that you’ll need to hand wash it every time. As long as you’re okay with doing so, it makes for a perfect pizza peel for small-time pizza baking.
6. Best Extra Large Pizza Peel - Kitchen Supply Aluminum Pizza Peel with Wood Handle
Wooden swivel handle folds away when not in use, saving lots of space
One of the largest blades of any pizza peel we’ve tested
Ultra-thin aluminum blade is easy to handle and maneuver pizzas with
Durable and long-lasting construction
- Paddle measures 14 x 16 inches
- Wooden swivel handle
- Aluminum blade
- Weighs 2.49 pounds
Larger than any other pizza peel we tested, only the Kitchen Supply Aluminum Pizza Peel is capable of handling your largest pizza projects. A hugely oversized 14 x 16 inch blade extends to nearly 30 inches long with the handle, making this peel capable of handling even an 18-inch extra large pizza.
You’ll need a fair bit of wrist, shoulder and forearm strength to wield this beast of a pizza peel, however. Its 2 ½ pound weight can be intimidating, and the added leverage of an extra long and wide construction will test your endurance during long days of cooking pizzas. Put in the work, though, and no other peel can handle big pizzas quite like the Kitchen Supply.
7. Best Long Pizza Peel - Chef Pomodoro Aluminum 9-Inch Turning Pizza Peel with Detachable Wood Handle
The longest pizza peel in our reviews, it’s perfect for turning pizzas inside of super hot ovens
Measures a whopping 47 inches with its additional handle extension
Extremely lightweight and easy to use
Disassembles for easy storage when not in use
Best when paired with a larger peel for pulling pizzas in and out of the oven
Really only meant for turning pizzas to ensure even cooking
- Paddle measures 9 inches in diameter
- Standard handle length: 28.6 inches
- Extended handle length: 47 inches
- Hard anodized aluminum head
- Perforated and tapered blade
- Weighs 1.6 pounds
If you’ve ever watched cooking pizza at a genuine wood-fired pizza oven, it’s a gradual process where you need to the pizza oven burning. You may already know that while the peel starts and finishes the baking process, another tool is responsible for even cooking. So, if you have the luxury of cooking in a wood-fired oven, we highly recommend investing in the Chef Pomodoro Aluminum Turning Peel to complement and round out your pizza equipment.
Fully extended, the Chef Pomodoro Turning Peel measures a huge 47 inches — more than enough length to let you precisely turn and manage your pizzas while they bake, rotating them to achieve even char across the entire pie.
Final Verdict: The Best Pizza Peel for the Money
After careful consideration of all the available options, only the Checkered Chef Extra Large Pizza Peel receives our highest recommendation as an all-purpose pizza peel. Its user-friendly design makes it a smash hit in almost any pizzeria or home kitchen, and the ultra-thin metal design made it extremely easy to accurately scoop and transport pizzas. If you’re unsure of which peel is right for you, take our advice and go with the Checkered Chef.
Of course, anyone on a tighter budget will find an excellent alternative to our top pick in the New Star Foodservice 50301 Wooden Pizza Peel. Completely wooden and charmingly old-school, it’s an attractive choice for anyone who prefers a more rustic style in their kitchen. And thanks to its super affordable price, it makes for an inexpensive addition to any home kitchen.
How to Choose the Best Pizza Peel
If you’ve never had the opportunity to handle a pizza peel, testing it and feeling out its weight and movement dynamics, you might find the idea of choosing one for yourself to be a daunting task.
Never fear: In the following sections, we’ll introduce you to the criteria we use to judge a pizza peel, as well as answer some of the most common questions that come up in this area.
Why Do You Need A Pizza Peel?
What is it that makes a pizza peel so special, anyway? Can’t you use any sort of flat surface to move your pizza around, or just bake it on a sheet pan and not worry about it?
In short, pizza peels have become an essential tool for use along with pizza stones, pizza ovens, and firewood (you need the right fuel to keep the pizza oven burning). These peels are the safest and most reliable way to transport your pies. For a small investment, you can guarantee that you’ll no longer have to deal with burnt arms, dropped pizzas, or undercooked crusts ever again.
What to Look for In A Pizza Peel
When deciding on which pizza peel is best for the money, consider the following five main attributes of a peel:
- Size is the primary measure of a pizza peel’s effectiveness. Without a decently sized head, you’ll be forever irritated by not being able to easily transport your pizzas. Don’t go any smaller than 12” x 14” for the head, or you won’t be able to cook the pizzas of your dreams.
- Handle Length can work for or against you, depending on how strong your arms and forearms are. Longer handles will keep you further away from your oven’s heat, but the added leverage puts extra strain on your wrists and shoulders. We prefer handles to be of a medium size, making them usable by just about anyone.
- Material can be wood, bamboo, or metal, with each having different maintenance requirements but generally working equally well for lifting and transporting pizzas. Choosing based on looks is a perfectly viable option.
- Construction should be sturdy and durable, with obvious thought and care put into the design. Look for peels that are solidly built, with strong connection points.
- Storage can be made much easier with peels that feature collapsible handles, but there is generally a tradeoff in comfort. If you need to cut back on storage space, go for a collapsible model; if not, a solid peel is a great choice.