7 Best Quesadilla Maker Options for Your Home Kitchen

    Last Updated on

    OUR TOP CHOICE

    OUR TOP CHOICE

    Key Features

     10-inch quesadilla making capacity

    Nonstick cooking surface

    Six deep-dish pockets

    Press and seal ridges

    Vertical storage

    Integrated cord wrap

    Cooks in 3-4 minutes


    Mexican dish

    Popular across the entire country of Mexico and made a household name in America by Tex-Mex restaurants in the south, the mouthwatering quesadilla is a quick and delicious option that’s perfect for a meal any time of day. 

    A simple combination of cheese and toppings pressed between two corn or flour tortillas, the quesadilla’s magical flavor comes more from how it’s made than what’s inside. That’s why, if you want to make the most authentic Mexican quesadillas, you’ll need a double-sided griddle that will perfectly sear both sides of your tortillas.

    Thankfully, you won’t have to start up a fire in the backyard to make traditional-style quesadillas — not if you have one of the 7 best quesadilla maker tools that we’ve reviewed and tested, that is!

    Read on to discover more about choosing the perfect electric quesadilla maker for your home, no matter what your budget is.

    Let’s get started!


    For the complete product list, please continue reading…


    Top 7 Best Quesadilla Maker Reviews

    1. Best Overall – George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker

    Pros:

     Perfect size for making a full meal for one person, or sharing with a crowd
     GeorgeTough nonstick surface is long-lasting and durable
     Super fast 3 to 4 minute cook time
     Divides quesadilla into six perfectly sealed pockets
     Compact storage thanks to its vertical design and integrated cord wrap

    Cons:

    Plastic shell is prone to easy wear and tear

    Specifications:

      • 10-inch quesadilla making capacity
      • Nonstick cooking surface
      • Six deep-dish pockets
      • Press and seal ridges
      • Vertical storage
      • Integrated cord wrap
      • Cooks in 3-4 minutes

    Aside from his fame as a heavyweight champion boxer, George Foreman may be best known for his invention of the world’s most popular indoor electric grill. Truly, George Foreman has revolutionized the home grilling scene — and his Electric Quesadilla Maker is just another excellent example of how the company continues to innovate.

    Perfectly sized to feed snacks to a family or make one generous full-sized meal, this 10-inch quesadilla maker features the same heavy duty non stick coating that made the original George Foreman grill famous. Shaped with specially designed ridges that press and seal your quesadilla into six even pockets, it sears tortillas to perfection in just 3 to 4 minutes — making it the fastest cooking quesadilla maker we tested.

    When you’re done using it, simply wipe off the cooking surfaces with a damp towel, return the cord to its integrated storage space, and store it upright in your cabinet.

    Our verdict: The George Foreman quesadilla maker is likely the best machine for the money out of dozens that we tested, and we highly recommend it for use in just about any kitchen.


    2. Largest Serving Size – Elite Cuisine EQD-118 Maxi-Matic 11″ Non-Stick Quesadilla Maker

    Pros:

    Largest quesadilla maker available on the market
     Perfect for making snacks for a whole party
     Generous interior capacity works well for overstuffed quesadillas
     Nonstick surface and drainage system make it easy to clean
     Stores conveniently out of the way thanks to an upright storage design

    Cons:

    Quite expensive

    Specifications:

      • Makes 11 inch quesadillas
      • Nonstick cooking surface
      • Cooks in 4-5 minutes
      • Includes a drainage rim and grease catching tray
      • Designed to store upright
      • Power and ready indicator lights
      • Locking front latch

    Featuring a super-deep 11-inch diameter cooking surface, the Elite Cuisine EQD-118 Maxi-Matic quesadilla maker has the distinction of serving the largest quesadillas around. We absolutely packed this machine full of toppings, and its generous cooking surface and foolproof drainage system made for perfectly grilled quesadillas every time.

    Better yet, the grease catching tray is complemented by a hardy nonstick cooking surface that makes cleanup a breeze. Once you’re done cooking, it’s easy to store this kitchen tool upright, saving space in your cabinets or on your counters.

    The only catch? A much larger size also comes with a larger price tag. But if you’re looking to invest in a quesadilla maker that can feed the whole family, Elite Cuisine is probably your best option.


    3. Best Single Serving – Nostalgia MGD5OR MyMini Personal Electric Griddle

    Pros:

     Lightweight, super compact, and easy to store when not in use
     Perfect for making single servings of quesadillas, pancakes, omelettes, and more
     Fast preheating
     Non-stick surface makes it easy to clean

    Cons:

     Does not create separations for sharing
     Kind of expensive for its size

    Specifications:

      • Makes 5 inch quesadillas
      • Takes 1-3 minutes to preheat
      • Dual-sided cooking surface
      • Cool touch handles
      • Measures just 6.75 inches wide
      • Weighs 1.32 pounds

    From the largest serving size to the smallest, Nostalgia’s MyMini Personal Electric Griddle is designed to be used not just for quesadillas, but also for mini pancakes, omelettes, and snacks. With a cooking surface just 5 inches in diameter, it’s perfectly sized for mini quesadillas — and heats quickly enough to cook a small snack in just under 5 minutes.

    For anyone who is strapped for space in the kitchen, the Nostalgia MyMini takes up barely any counter space at all at just under 7 inches wide. While it’s not the best choice for making multiple servings, it may be the best option available for anyone cooking quesadillas for one.


    4. Best Compact – Dash DMG8100AQ 8” Express Electric Round Griddle

    Pros:

     Versatile and useful for making omelettes, cookies, pancakes, and grilled cheese sandwiches
     Excellent for single serving size quesadillas
     Non-slip feet make it ideal for use in an RV or camper
     Compact size and upright storage make it a perfect fit for small apartments
     Comes with a 1-year warranty to protect your kitchen investment

    Cons:

     Does not make divisions for sharing
     Quesadillas can’t be very thick

    Specifications:

      • Makes 8 inch quesadillas
      • Preheats in under two minutes
      • Anti-slip feet
      • Double-sided non stick cooking surfaces
      • Includes a recipe book
      • Comes with a 1-year manufacturer’s warranty

    Compact enough to take up almost no space in your cabinets, yet just large enough to make a single full-size meal, the Dash Express Electric Round Griddle is another option that’s great for more than just quesadillas. Pre-heating in less than two minutes, it can cook up a delicious Mexican meal in as little as three minutes — making it on par with our top pick in cooking speed.

    We especially appreciate the anti-slip feet on the Dash electric griddle, as they are a feature not found in many other quesadilla makers. While you won’t be actively moving your quesadilla around while cooking, these feet help to prevent any accidental damage from bumping it while it cooks.

    Lastly, the Dash is one of only a few quesadilla makers in our review to feature a 1-year warranty. That’s just enough time to protect your kitchen equipment investment, and is another reason that we recommend this for anyone looking for a compact quesadilla maker.


    5. Easiest Cleanup – Nostalgia Taco Tuesday Deluxe 8-Inch 6-Wedge Electric Quesadilla Maker with Extra Stuffing Latch

    Pros:

     Incredibly durable non-stick surfaces and built-in drip tray make it the easiest quesadilla maker to clean of any we tested
     Adjustable latch allows for double-stuffing your quesadillas
     Unique lid design creates perfect sealed pockets that are great for sharing
     Vertical storage and compact design make it easy to store when not in use

    Cons:

     Long preheating time
     Takes quite a while to cook

    Specifications:

      • Makes 8 inch quesadillas
      • Lid design creates six sealed sectional pieces
      • Two-position latch accommodates extra stuffing
      • Non-stick cooking surfaces
      • Built-in drip tray
      • Vertical storage

    Similar to the Dash griddle featured above, but with the addition of specialized cooking plates specific to quesadillas, the Nostalgia Taco Tuesday electric quesadilla maker is an excellent alternative for a compact quesadilla maker that is easy to clean.

    Featuring an 8-inch cooking surface with some of the best non-stick coating of any machine we tested, it’s also equipped with a built-in drip tray for super fast cleanup. After you’ve cooked your meal, all you’ll need to do is remove the drip tray and wipe the surfaces down with a damp towel.

    We especially enjoy the two-position latch on this quesadilla maker from Nostalgia, as it allows for double stuffing your personal-sized quesadillas.


    6. Most Versatile – Betty Crocker BC-2958CR Quesadilla Maker

    Pros:

     Large, deep cooking surface can make quesadillas, pizzas, quiche, giant cookies, and more
     Powerful electric heating element cooks quickly and evenly
     Non-stick coating makes for fast and easy cleanup
     Durable metal body is built to last for years

    Cons:

     Expensive
     Bulky and somewhat difficult to store

    Specifications:

      • Makes 12 inch quesadillas
      • 1440 watts of power
      • Metal body
      • Nonstick coated baking plates
      • Integrated cord wrap

    Though often advertised as an electric pizza maker, Betty Crocker’s BC-2958CR has long been one of our favorite kitchen tools to use for making quesadillas, too. Though it lacks the indentations that make restaurant-style indentations in your quesadillas, the huge 12 inch cooking surface makes it incredibly versatile for cooking a wide variety of foods.

    This quesadilla maker is far from being lightweight, however, thanks to its all-metal body. While this gives it greater durability than any other machine in our review, it also makes it the bulkiest and most difficult to store.

    With a massive 1440 watts of power, this quesadilla maker is set to cook anything you put in it in record time. We recommend it for anyone that regularly cooks for groups, and wants a machine that’s good for much more than just quesadillas.


    7. Best Value – Hamilton Beach Quesadilla Maker

    Pros:

     Very affordable
     Cooks quesadillas quickly and evenly
     Easy to clean thanks to its non stick cooking surfaces
     Compact vertical storage design

    Cons:

    Plastic latch is prone to cracking

    Specifications:

      • Makes 8 inch quesadillas
      • Cooks in about 5 minutes
      • Nonstick cooking surfaces
      • Lid design creates six wedges
      • Locking lid
      • Includes a recipe book
      • Designed for upright storage

    Remarkably inexpensive yet boasting many of the same design features of our top picks, the Hamilton Beach quesadilla maker receives our recommendation for the best bargain-priced quesadilla maker. It’s compact 8-inch cooking surface is best for single servings, though the lid design also creates six even wedges that can make it useful for serving small appetizers or snacks.

    Were it not for the plastic latch that is prone to chipping and cracking, we would have gladly rated this quesadilla maker in our top three picks. For the money though, it’s hard to beat its easy, compact storage and quick cooking times — making its fragile plastic body more of a small flaw than a dealbreaker.


    Final Verdict

    George Foreman GFQ001

    Check Price on Amazon Check Price on Walmart

     

    From one of the biggest names in modern day grilling cookware, the George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker easily takes our top spot as the best quesadilla maker for the money. It’s remarkably affordable, generously sized, and extremely easy to clean — all in addition to superfast cooking times and easy storage. In short, you’d be hard-pressed to find a better quesadilla maker for most any home.

    If you’re looking for a multi-purpose griddle that can handle quesadillas, pizzas, flatbreads, and nachos for a whole family, the Hamilton Beach Quesadilla Maker is the only way to go. It’s deep and spacious 12-inch cooking surface makes it the largest and most versatile quesadilla maker on our list.


    How to Choose the Best Quesadilla Maker

    Not all quesadilla makers are created equally. So how do you know which one is best for your home and kitchen? Follow along as we discuss three important topics to consider before deciding which quesadilla maker to purchase.

    What to Look for In A Quesadilla Maker

    When you’re evaluating any quesadilla maker, you can judge it based on four primary characteristics:

    • Size. How large is the cooking surface? Common sizes include 5, 6, 8, and 10 inch diameters, while anything smaller or larger than that range is more difficult to find. For most people, an 8 to 10 inch quesadilla maker will be just the right size for a full meal for one, or snacks for 2-3 people.
    • Power. Can it cook your quesadilla quickly? We’ve selected only those quesadilla makers that can sear a delicious meal to perfection in around 5 minutes or less.
    • Cleanup. Is it difficult to clean after you’re done using it? The best quesadilla makers are coated in a durable non-stick film, and some come with an added grease tray to protect your counters as well.
    • Storage. Since you might not want your quesadilla maker out on your countertop all the time, it’s best to look for models that are easy to store when not in use.

    Types of Quesadilla Makers

    While technically there are cast iron quesadilla makers for use over an open fire, if you’re looking to cook au natural, it’s better to simply cook them on a flat top grill. 

    That means that for all other quesadilla makers, you’ll be looking at buying an electric model. Most electric quesadilla makers will have a plastic body to help them remain lightweight, portable, and affordable; if you’re looking for the longest-lasting models available, metal housings will cost more but last much longer.

    Other Uses for Quesadilla Makers

    While some quesadilla makers come with specialized indentations that make them most suitable only for quesadillas, many others act as a double-sided griddle. This can be great for cooking a wide variety of foods, and will give you greater versatility in the kitchen — making them a doubly worthwhile investment.