Last Updated on
In A Rush?
“Grilling, broiling, barbecuing – whatever you want to call it – is an art, not just a matter of building a pyre and throwing on a piece of meat as a sacrifice to the gods of the stomach.”
So says James Beard, an American culinary expert, a champion of American cuisine and lover of the grill.
Do you agree?
But for the art of grilling to come full circle, one thing must be part of the equation: the very best Weber grill.
Weber produces high quality grills that use charcoal, LP propane, natural gas or electricity for fuel. Our guide shows you the best grilling options from Weber and we tell you why we think the Weber 7170001 Summit S-470 4-Burner Liquid Propane Grill is the best Weber gas grill.
But first, are you ready to find out what types of grills Weber has in store for you?
Types of Weber Grills
Weber gas grills are the most popular ones with buyers, because they use natural gas or LP propane.
So what if they use propane or natural gas, I hear you say?
Well, both types of fuel are clean and highly portable. Natural gas grills especially cater to grilling enthusiasts who want to leave a small carbon footprint.
But I have also discovered the real truth behind their popularity.
I believe it lies in the fact that gas grills fire up quickly, so a backyard barbeque or a grilling during a camping trip can be organized in a matter of minutes. There is nothing holding you back from a barbeque every other day.
As the name suggests, these are electricity-powered grills that are fitted with grill plates. The grill plates are heated up electrically, so no fire is needed to grill.
Just like with gas grills, there is no messy cleanup process after using the grill.
Weber produces both indoor and outdoor electric grills.
Who is the best clientele for an electric grill?
Urban dwellers living in a condo or apartment love these types of grills. They are the best option if you live within an area with strict fire regulation laws. These regulations typically prohibit the use of gas or charcoal in grilling.
Have you ever had grilled steak with grill marks and a charred smoky flavor? Then you know that charcoal is the best grilling fuel on the planet.
I know. It is a festival of smoky flavor in your mouth.
Forget the grill marks with no charred flavor that you find with other grills. Charcoal grills are for the purist grilling enthusiast who understands the importance of searing meat to lock in the juices while the high temperature burning charcoal imparts its signature smoky flavor.
But with a charcoal grill, you need time and patience and some mastery in handling the meat on the fast burning fuel. So, if you like to take your time grilling, a charcoal grill is your trusted partner.
There is the downside of cleaning up and disposing of the charcoal and ash after use. This is perhaps the number one reason why most people prefer the cleaner electric and gas grills.
Another disadvantage of using charcoal grills is that charcoal is expensive compared to propane or natural gas.
In the next section you are going to learn about our top 10 picks of Weber grills and what makes them stand out.
Top 10 Best Weber Grill Reviews 2019
Look, I can tell you right now that this propane grill is a crowd puller. It can smoke, grill, and rotisserie your meats and birds to perfection. This is the type of grill that inspires weekend hangouts at your place.
Wondering why it is called the S-470?
Because the Weber-Summit S-470 offers users 470 square inches of cooking space, so you can grill up a storm. The warming rack is 112 square inches, so you have no excuse to serve cold food, ever!
This grill is perfect for someone looking for an average-size grill, with features like a side burner and a smoker burner. My favorite feature on it is the sear station burner. This guarantees that the meat will have a perfect sear on the outside, and juicy tenderness on the inside.
When it comes to its construction, the height is comfortable without making in necessary for tall people to hunch. It does not have a very sleek design, but at least it is not boxy.
Still on the fence about it?
What if I told you that they sweetened the deal by putting in an infrared rotisserie burner?
Yes. The rear-mounted rotisserie burner is indeed infrared, meaning natural gas heats up the infrared element, which in turn radiates heat to your bird, slowly cooking her.
This is one of the easiest grills to fire up and use. It has been well thought-out and the construction is sturdy for an outdoor grill. It is just big enough for entertaining a small crowd of friends and family. Plus, it is the best Weber gas grill for the money.
Right off the bat: I love the loud brazen red color of this grill. I tested the red one, but you can get it in sapphire, black or ivory. I guess I went for the red because the first generation Weber Spirit grill was only available in stainless steel or black. I needed something that was a far cry from the plainness of stainless steel.
After a few uses, I can tell you with utmost certainty:
The Spirit II E-310 Weber grill is capable of producing the most amazing ribs.
The Spirit II and Genesis II Weber grills have two things in common: first, they both come fitted with the Weber GS4 high performance grilling system. Second, they are both compatible with the iGrill 3 temperature probe. This means you can grill your meat at the right temperature without over- or undercooking.
I found the experiencing of using the Spirit II to be much more enhanced that its predecessor because of these upgrades. The grill ignites faster, since it uses the GS4 infinity ignition which is part of the GS4 high performance system.
I enjoy using Weber grills that have porcelain on the grates, and this model has porcelain enameled steel grates. That type of grate guarantees even grilling of the meat, because the entire grate heats up at the same time and retains heat evenly.
The features on the Spirit II and the first generation Spirit are not too far apart, which made me curious about why Weber brought the newer model into the market. At close inspection, the improvements are in areas that consumers gipped about most, like the position of the propane tank and lack of a storage cart. And that is what sets Weber apart from other grill manufacturers – they listen to their customers.
I am sure I mentioned somewhere in here that I love portable grills. And the Q1200 is one of my favorites.
I also think by now it is clear I am sucker for color on my grills, and this model comes in an array of fantastic colors: red, green, fuschia, black, blue, orange and titanium.
Okay, yes. My favorite color is still red but that is not the reason I consider this the best portable grill.
Here is why:
First, it ticks all the boxes on functionality and practicality, which are crucial considerations when you are out in the wild with a grill. The construction is sturdy and it is easy to clean. It can fit on a patio or small backyard and it fires up fast.
Second, it has cast iron grates for even grilling. It also has a porcelain enameled cooking surface that is easy to clean after use. Plus, 189 square inches of cooking space is more than adequate for a portable grill.
And third, as if all the above wasn’t enough; it looks great in any color!
This is the grill to carry when you have a small group of campers, because you can cook enough without slaving over the grill in small batches to get everyone fed.
It may be bulky, but I think the overall features justify the bulk. A smaller grill may not be able to handle the rigors of the outdoors, especially if it used for activities like camping. The addition of side tables and the use of materials like cast iron add to the overall weight, but they also guarantee efficiency.
I have come to understand the dome design of the kettle charcoal grill. That dome traps the smoke and soon the meat soaks up the flavor and tastes like it was roasted on open camp fire. I didn’t get it before and would bypass such grills when shopping in the past.
The cooking surface area on the Performer Deluxe grill is 363 square inches, meaning it is not tiny, but it is not too bulky either. It is just enough to hold food for a small party.
I am also impressed by the ignition mechanism which is just a button. If you know how messy lighting charcoal can get, then you understand my enthusiasm over a button.
The grill offers users prep room, so that you can do all your food preparation in one place.
But my favorite aspect of this grill is the cart bottom that Weber used instead of the traditional three legs. It looks like a gas grill with a charcoal grill top.
But here is the best part:
This model has an aluminized steel one-touch cleaning system. Combine that with the porcelain enameled grate and this is a very easy grill to clean after use.
This charcoal grill has been built to match the convenience of a gas or electric grill. It is cleaner than most charcoal options and you still enjoy the pure taste of charcoal grilled meat.
You may be wondering why the Summit range of Weber grills makes my top picks.
The truth is that this range of Weber grill has the best functionality and features.
Take this Summit S-670 grill for example.
Not only is it a beast in size, it is fitted with the best features that I love on a grill.
From having 10 burners to the closed cart where I can store my grilling tools, I find this grill convenient and fast.
Over and above the features, which truly shape your grilling experience, the fact that this grill uses natural gas over propane makes it a winner for me.
Think about it:
You can feed an entire village on natural gas! How environmentally-friendly and efficient is that? I love clean energy, and this grill feeds my love for the environment and my stomach at the same time.
I promise you that you can cook everything and anything on the Summit S-670.
And yes! The “670” stands for 670 square inches of cooking space.
Plus, it also has the infrared rotisserie burner.
Gift the Weber Summit S-670 grill to a friend living off the grid. If that friend is you, even better! This is an environment-friendly grill for a user who wants efficiency with a small carbon footprint.
There are few things that are equal part delicate and hard as porcelain. Which begs the question: why would Weber use a delicate material on a grill?
Let me break this down:
The porcelain on the grates is of the highest grade, which also happens to be the hardest and strongest.
But that is not the reason it is used here.
Porcelain is a good conductor of heat and it retains heat very well too. Cast iron is also revered for its ability to conduct and retain heat. Porcelain and cast iron together keep the grate at an even heat, guaranteeing that your meat will be grilled evenly as well.
Here is why this is so important:
It gives the meat the perfect sear. That is why I call this grill the sear master.
The total cooking area is 669 square inches, enough room for you and your best friend to grill some burgers and assemble them side by side while catching up.
When it comes to the design, I like the fact that the propane gas tank is side mounted. Before they changed this configuration (myself and others among you) would always, without fail, have difficulty finding where we should put the gas cylinder.
The Genesis II series of Weber grills is compatible with the iGrill 3 temperature probe, which allows you to monitor all the meats on the grill at the same time via your smartphone. This is a smart and efficient grilling partner. The use of technology to add convenience plus the quality of materials used make this the best Genesis II grill I have tried so far.
The genesis II S-435 has four burners and it heats up fast and easily. But then gas grills always do.
What they don’t do, however, is sync your grill with your phone, so you can keep tabs on the grilling and cooking from anywhere in the house (and a few places outside). The Genesis II E-335 above does though.
This is the biggest incentive for me to get this grill. It is perfect for a multi-tasker like me, and it’s all courtesy of iGrill 3.
I can grill several meats, sauté veggies on one burner and simmer some sauce in the side burner AND still have room left for more cooking.
I know. Sounds like I am a crazy scientist on the grill, but the Genesis II S-435 is highly efficient, so you can get it going on different fronts simultaneously. Read on for the pros and cons to learn what makes this grill infamous.
I would recommend the Genesis II S-435 as the first Weber grill anyone should buy. It will introduce you to the brand without overwhelming you with features and size. Besides, it looks great and grills impressively, making you look like a pro.
I haven’t come across a neater Weber gas grill than the Spirit II E-210. It is more compact than the Spirit II E-310, and has fewer knobs, giving it a very clean interface.
In keeping with the spirit of the Spirit II series (yes, I know) this model also comes in fun colors, red being my favorite. You can also get it in sapphire, black and stainless steel.
The Weber Spirit II range is an entry level series developed to cater to someone learning to grill. It is also ideal for a small family. The overall construction is sturdy and although it lacks the features that most seasoned grillers are accustomed to, it does a good job of searing and evenly grilling the meat.
Even a seasoned grilling enthusiast like me can’t fault its performance.
I believe it was a great idea to have the porcelain enameled cast iron grates on this particular model, because it makes it easier for a beginner to achieve an even grill. Plus, we don’t want to scare beginners away from grilling by giving them the hardest grill to clean. This model is easy to clean and maintain.
The interface on this grill is a winner. It looks basic but it performs like the high-end Weber options without the confusing features. It is an ideal choice for anyone starting out in the grilling game. And in case you are wondering, 360 square inches of cooking space is more than sufficient for a beginner.
Another contender for my affection for portable grills is the Weber Q3200. What can I say? I like to take my grilling with me everywhere I go.
This model has a futuristic look which if you ask me adds to its charm.
But here is what it can really do:
It offers users two stainless steel burners, so you can cook entire meals for a large group. I appreciate the workhorse nature of this grill and clearly Weber created it to withstand consistent use, because the body and lid are both cast iron.
Why does that matter so much? Stay with me for a moment.
We have established that cast iron retains heat. This grill’s grates are made from cast iron and porcelain which also retain heats. If the overall construction is aimed at retaining heat, that means this grill is built to be a very fast cooker!
Pure genius on the part of Weber!
Plus, it is environmentally-friendly because it uses natural gas.
For small backyard parties and camping trips with family and friend, this is a great option. You can fire it up fast and cook fast as well.
The kettle design is synonymous with most charcoal grills from Weber. This design makes it easy to enjoy a barbeque grill on your patio or small backyard, because it makes the grill more compact. The big dome is not only stylish, but it also facilitates faster cooking.
But here is why this is the best Weber charcoal grill I have sampled so far.
It has a hinged grate that stays in place even when you are stoking the fire and adding more charcoal to the grill. This may seem basic, but after using grills with unstable grates that sacrifice my meat to the ashes below, I appreciate one that stays in place.
The cooking surface area is 393 square inches, and allowing users to put on multiple foods. The use of porcelain enameled grates ensures the grill retains heat throughout the grilling process. And thereafter it is very easy to clean.
Anyone who loves charcoal grilling will find this grill efficient and effective. And knowing how annoying the clean up can be, the inclusion of an excellent ash catcher is welcome. At least you won’t have ash spilling all over the place with this grill. And the copper finish is unique.
Finding the right grill should be easier now using our Weber grill reviews. So which one will you choose?
You have an array of excellent grills ranging from the simplest to the more complex, feature-packed options. I highly recommend the Weber 7170001 Summit S-470 4-Burner Liquid Propane Grill, because it is has the perfect balance of features and functionality. All the controls are front-mounted and it is easy to navigate during use and clean after . If you are looking for a medium sized gas grill from Weber, for this holiday season I highly recommend the Summit S-470.
But whatever you choose, you are guaranteed an excellent grilled feast.
How to Choose a Weber Grill
There is one rule to remember when shopping for a Weber grill: you get what you pay for.
Weber grills are not cheap grocery store models, but they aren’t ridiculous $10,000 grills either. They are efficient and modern with excellent features to enhance the grilling experience, giving them a mid-range price point.
Depending on the model, you could spend between $500 and $2000. When comparing the costs, look at what is included in the price, like propane tanks or grill covers.
If these are included, that is a generous offer. Don’t pass it up!
I love a portable grill. Just the thought of firing it up to barbeque some tender steaks fires me up (pun intended).
And Weber offers some of the best ones on the market.
The brand also has larger grills and their gas grills are their biggest models. Some of the best Weber gas grills feature up to 10 burners making them ideal for cooking for large groups.
The charcoal grills are medium in size and have a Kettle design. They can cook for small groups and families. The portable grills are the most compact, meaning they are not built to cater to crowds.
There are only two materials that you should even remotely consider in a grill, and Weber grills have them. One is cast aluminum which will probably outlive you and a few more generation after you. And the second is stainless steel. Both materials are easy to clean, corrosion resistant and durable.
For grates, the brand offers three choices in materials: porcelain enameled cast-iron, stainless steel and porcelain enameled steel.
Porcelain enameled cast-iron and porcelain enameled steel are easier to clean compared to the stainless steel.
The main frame of the grills is made of heavy duty steel and cast aluminum, and this applies to all their grills.
Weber grills are either gas, charcoal or electric. For a traditional grilling experience, you can use charcoal, but for a modern one, gas or electric grills are more than adequate.
It is important to consider what type of fuel is readily available to you when choosing a Weber grill. Also, research regulations about certain types of fuel in your neighborhood.
If you want a grill that gets the job done quickly, then choose a smaller, compact model with a high BTU rating. The higher the BTU number of the burners, the higher the heat capacity. However, if the grill is too big, the heat is quickly lost. But with a compact model, most of the heat is retained, allowing you to cook faster.
A grill can get upgraded so that it becomes more efficient and fun to work with. For example, it can be fitted with a smoke box, or a rotisserie burner or a side burner. And it can also come with multiple levels of cooking surfaces.
What you choose will depend on your needs. Because here is the truth:
The more features, the higher the cost!
Who needs a rotisserie burner that drives the price up by $50 to $100 dollars, when you can grill your chicken the regular way?