Campchef VS Traeger Pellet Grills: Which One Wins

    Last Updated on

    OUR TOP CHOICE

    OUR TOP CHOICE

    Key Features

    Smart Smoke technology keeps cooking temperature within 15 degrees

    Wheeled legs make it easy to move

    2 layers of grill top for extra cooking space

    Easy to clean with trap door design

    Slide and Grill technology switches between direct and indirect flame


    CAMP CHEF VS TRAEGER 4

    When it comes to picking the perfect grill, there are a lot of factors that might go into your decision. Quality is a prime factor, as you want to make sure you buy a grill that lasts. Depending on how much you grill or the number of people you would normally be cooking for, the size and capacity of the grill may also be a consideration.

    Whether you plan to use it permanently in your backyard or pack it with you on a camping trip may determine the type of grill that is best for you. Also, the cost is a factor, as grills can have a wide price range. You won’t go wrong with a Camp Chef or a Traeger grill, both of which offer options for quality, size, price point, and portability.

    Each of these grills has a number of specific features and qualities, aimed at a particular purpose or style of grilling. You may want a certain number of burners or prefer a smoke flavor. These grills offer several options, and you can pick the one that’s more suitable for you based on your preferences. For a great all-around, portable grill, the Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 Wood Pellet Grill is an excellent choice. 

    Brand Overviews

    Camp Chef and Traeger are both well-known, high-quality grill manufacturers that make great cookers for the outdoors. While the Camp Chef brand makes many kinds of grills aimed at versatility for people who love the outdoors and traveling, Traeger specifically makes pellet grills. As the original inventor of pellet grills, Traeger has perfected this art, with Camp Chef and many other manufacturers imitating and improving on Traeger’s expired patent. 

    Both grill companies craft great grills that make cooking and barbequing a fun experience. When picking between the two, consider how often you use it, where you will use it, and how much space you have for it. Based on that, you can determine your budget, the type of grill, and what your primary uses might be.


    CAMP CHEF BRAND

    As the brand name suggests, Camp Chef grills are designed for camping and portability, providing you great cooking experiences wherever you go. Since 1990, Camp Chef has been making grills for the outdoor men and women who want to take their cooking experience outside while camping or tailgating.

    They first started with camping grills, flat-top grills, and portable grills, making high-quality products that were well-designed, practical, and efficient. Since, they have made pellet grills, pizza ovens, dutch ovens, stoves, and much more. They have also made a number of attachments or add-ons to work with their cookers.

    Camp Chef is well-known for making durable grills that can easily endure travel and outdoor camping setups. The quality of their products is seen in the continued use you will get out of it cooking by rivers, mountains, deserts, and more for dozens of camping trips to come.


    TRAEGER BRAND

    When it comes to pellet grills, Traeger is a well-known brand that delivers a high-end barbeque experience. Traeger made the first and original pellet grill, designing and patenting its unique cooker in the mid-1980s.

    On the outside, Traeger grills look a lot like a traditional smoker. The main difference is that instead of a smoke box, they have installed a wood pellet hopper. An internal mechanism and auger light the wood pellets to create heat and smoke, cooking your food with a lot of extra smoke and flavors.

    This technology was developed by Traeger and has revolutionized the outdoor cooking experience. Traeger’s patent expired in 2006, which allowed a number of competing grill manufacturers to make their own pellet grills with the same groundbreaking technology.


    Here is the list of the best treager and camp chef grills to buy

    For the complete product list, please continue reading…


    Camp Chef vs. Traeger Review

    1. Best Overall – Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 Wood Pellet Grill

    Pros:

    Smart Smoke technology keeps cooking temperature within 15 degrees
    Wheeled legs make it easy to move
    2 layers of grill top for extra cooking space
    Easy to clean with trap door design
    Slide and Grill technology switches between direct and indirect flame

    Cons:

    May be more advanced than some grillers need

    Specifications:

      • Grill Dimensions: 16″ x 38″
      • Cooking Surface Area: 811 sq. in.
      • Cooking Height: 30″
      • Weight: 22 lbs.
      • Pellet hopper capacity: 22 lbs.

    The Camp Chef SmokePro SG Wood Pellet Grill is a staple in the pellet grilling world, used by many in campsites, backyards, and patios all across America. Simple, to-the-point, and effective, this pellet grill provides versatility and ease of use one. It is lightweight and has wheeled legs, which is one of its best features, letting you transport it and set it up in only a few minutes.

    The two layers provide ample cooking space, letting you prepare meals for a big group of people at once. This grill has two large cooking surfaces and can put out a total of 25,000 BTUs per hour, making it great for big cookouts and holiday weekends.

    It has a large pellet hopper capacity of 22 lbs., letting you smoke and grill with delicious flavor for hours. Its top rack is great for keeping things warm throughout the day or cooking food at different temperatures. For simple cleaning, it has a removable ash cleanout trap door system.

    It features a digital temperature display that can show cooking temperature or internal food temperature. The SmokePro SG has Slide and Grill technology, letting easily alternate between direct and indirect flames for different cooking modes. Its digital display can show you the temperature of the grill as well as internal meat temperature, letting you monitor and cook your food precisely.


    2. Best Runner Up – Traeger Grills TFB38TOD Renegade Pro Pellet Grill and Smoker

    Pros:

    Digital Pro Controller provides Advanced Grilling Logic Precision
    Durable steel construction and powder coat finish
    Wood pellets provide a lot of flavor
    Fits 12 hamburgers or 3 racks of ribs
    Features Dual Meat Temperature Probes

    Cons:

    Cleaning can be tedious for some
    Can burn too hot for low-temperature cooking

    Specifications:

      • Grill Dimensions: 27″ x 39″
      • Cooking Surface Area: 380 sq. in.
      • Cooking Height: 50”
      • Weight: 109 lbs.
      • Pellet hopper capacity: 18 lbs.

    The Traeger Grills TFB38TOD Renegade Pro is a great pellet grill and smoker, built out of premium steel, and finished in a durable powder coat.

    It features a Digital Pro Controller that helps provide Advanced Grilling Logic Precision, making for the perfect grill settings every time. It is a wood pellet grill and cooks your food using the flavor of the pellets. You can load up to 18 pounds of wood pellets at one time, letting you store enough for a few cooks. The grill top can fit 12 burgers, 2 whole chickens, or 3 racks of ribs, which is plenty for a large gathering.

    This Traeger grill is a great choice for those who take grilling seriously and want the best flavor to cook with. Cooking with pellets lets you flavor your food with different wood smoke, giving your barbeque a full, smoky taste.

    The digital temperature control and ability to reach precise temperatures lets veteran grillers perfect their favorite cuts of meat or roast vegetables. The veteran griller can enjoy the ability to fine-tune their grilling experience, as well as use different kinds of wood pellets for different cookouts.

    This grill provides the versatility to grill, bake, braise, smoke, roast, and BBQ. It also looks great and has all-terrain wheels and a side left bar for easy moving, making it a great backyard component for your weekend and holiday cookouts.


    3. Best Budget – Camp Chef SmokePro Stainless DLX Pellet Grill w/ New PID Gen 2 Digital Controller

    Pros:

    Gets up to 350°F within 30 minutes
    Powder-coated stainless steel that holds up in rain and snow
    Small top rack for extra space
    Can be purchased with a propane sear box to reach higher temperatures

    Cons:

    Controller not compatible with Wi-Fi
    Doesn’t get hot enough to sear a steak

    Specifications:

      • 40.5” x 25” x 22” overall dimensions
      • 19.5″ x 22″ grilling area dimensions:
      • 6″ x 24″ Smoking/Warming Rack Dimensions:
      • Hopper can accommodate up to 18 lbs. of pellets
      • Generation 2 PID controller by Camp Chef

    This affordable option doubles as a backyard grill and smoker, making it excellent for barbeque enthusiasts.

    Novice grill masters find it easy to control the temperature and perfectly cook everything from hamburgers to corn-on-the-cob thanks to the digital heat control system. This automatically feeds the fire with pellets to keep the temperature consistent, and it also provides information on the cooking temperature and internal meat temperature upon request.

    Grilling over compressed wood pellets is what gives barbeque its rich, smokey flavor. To really highlight the taste, turn down the heat and slow cook a brisket or whole chicken for an irresistible tender main course. This grill covers the entire cooking range with high and low smoke settings and a temperature range from 160° to over 400°F.

    This grill comes with a built-in grease drain and removable ash can so you don’t have to bother with a lengthy clean-up after each cookout. These are patented cleanout systems that reflect the careful design of the product.

    The stainless steel construction makes this grill a durable and handsome piece. At 127 pounds, it’s sturdy enough to stay where you put it, but remains mobile with 2 wheels to move it to the perfect location. You’ll also get a large cooking space that provides enough room for multi-family cookouts.


    4. Best High Tech – Traeger Pro 575 Wi-Fi Controlled Wood Pellet Grill

    Pros:

    Great for cooking for large families
    Multiple ways to cook food, depending on your style and preference
    Features WiFIRE control to monitor from a smartphone

    Cons:

    Users have reported issues with firmware updates
    Requires 2 people to assemble it

    Specifications:

      • Grill Dimensions: 41” x 27”
      • Cooking Surface Area: 575 sq. in.
      • Cooking Height: 53”
      • Weight: 128 lbs.
      • Pellet hopper capacity: 18 lbs.

    With the ability to connect to your smartphone or even collude with Alexa, this grill is a smart grill with a large cooking capacity. The 575 square inches of cooking area and an 18-pound hopper ensure that you can cook for throngs and still have pellets left over. With tons of different flavors of pellets to smoke with, this grill and smoker cooks your meats with indirect heat.

    This unit also has versatility in that it can cook hot and fierce, or low and long. From BBQing to charring to braising for hours on end, this grill does it all. No more worrying about flare-ups, constantly shoving pellets into a hopper or uneven cooking: This grill is a great fit for novices and pitmasters.

    The high-tech software in this unit controls a convection fan and the automatic auger, which Traeger calls the D2 Direct Drive, for smooth pellet feeding and even cooking, enhanced even more by the excellent wood-fired flavor. It even has a sensor to let you know when the hopper is running low so you’re not surprised.

    You can even control and monitor your food with your smartphone or voice-controlled digital assistant. Standing over a hot grill is a thing of the past. No more watching over the grill while the rest of the party has fun; now you can cook and enjoy the festivities. For all of the features this grill provides, it’s also offered at an affordable price point.


    5. Best for Digital Control – Camp Chef PG24XT Smoke Pro Pellet BBQ with Digital Controls

    Pros:

    Grease management system
    Built-in temperature gauge
    Large cooking area
    Ash cleanout system

    Cons:

    The controller may overflow the burn cup
    Temperatures swings reported

    Specifications:

      • Grill Dimensions: 40.5” x 25”
      • Cooking Surface Area: 570 sq. in.
      • Cooking Height: 22”
      • Weight: 133 lbs.
      • Advanced digital temperature system

    With a temperature range from 160 up to 500°F, this grill and smoker can handle any cooking technique you want to throw at it. Smoke, bake, roast, char, braise, or grill, this unit has the ability, precise control, and surface area to handle almost any challenge.

    If you’re looking for a versatile unit with enough surface area to accommodate a lot of food, this is the grill for you. With this Pro Pellet BBQ, you can set your digital control and largely forget about the smoker, unless you want to periodically spritz the meat.

    It’s incredibly easy to cook your meat precisely and maintain even temps throughout with the smart digital temp control, which keeps your grill at exactly the right heat.

    The automatic auger dispenses the pellets at a steady pace to keep a level cooking time. The manufacturer’s patented Ash Cleanout system makes maintenance a breeze and flare-ups a thing of the past.

    The removable ash cup and adjustable smoke chimney let you specialize your grill to your own expectations, and the extra-large hopper keeps you cooking for long periods. With a push of a button, you can toggle the grill temperature or use the meat probe to check the internal temperature of any of your dishes. 

    With some of the most recent advancements in grilling technology and temperature control, this grill and smoker can do it all at your next BBQ event. You don’t have to babysit this grill; just set it and let it do all the work for you.


    6. Best User-Friendly – Traeger Grills Pro Series 22 Pellet Grill & Smoker

    Pros:

    Accommodates 24 burgers, 4 chickens, or 5 racks of ribs
    No gas or charcoal uses pellets
    Digital Pro Controller keeps temps within precise grilling range
    Comes with meat thermometers to keep track of cooking time
    Can slow roast, grill, smoke, bake, braise, or char to recipes’ specifications

    Cons:

    May not hold always temp

    Specifications:

      • Grill Dimensions: 27” by 41”
      • Cooking Surface Area: 572 sq. in.
      • Cooking Height: 49”
      • Weight: 103 lbs.
      • Superb wood-fired taste

    This pellet grill and smoker help make even a novice griller or barbeque-er stand out. For experienced outdoor cooking enthusiasts, this grill can hone your many techniques, like braising, slow roasting, and grilling. The 6-in-1 versatility makes this grill more than just an outdoor cooker. You may find yourself baking an apple pie or smoking pork butt for pulled pork.

    This grill isn’t lightweight enough at 103 pounds to be portable, but it makes up for this in sturdiness.

    With a 572 square inch cooking area, it’s great for multiple chickens cut into pieces, 2 dozen hamburgers, or 5 racks of lamb, along with other tasty nibbles. And with a hopper capacity of 18 lbs., you can cook for long periods. Unlike other charcoal and propane grills, this provides even cooking with minimal hot spots.

    This grill makes any grilling technique viable because it makes it simple. The combo of the digital thermometer and automatic auger elevates any chef’s skills to sublime. With a steel sheet above the firebox and another steel sheet to direct grease run-off, you don’t have to worry about flame-ups. It also makes clean-ups a breeze; simply remove the collection bucket and clean.

    Not only that, but this unit comes with 2 meat thermometers that attach straight to the grill for instant readouts. This grill is a superb marriage of practicality and modern technology. 


    Final Verdict: Camp Chef vs. Traeger

    SmokePro SGCheck Price on Amazon

     

    When it comes to choosing between two great grilling brands, Camp Chef and Traeger offer a number of great features, and it can be hard to choose. Using a pellet grill can bring your barbequing experience to the next level, by providing the smokey wood flavor that makes great grilled meals.

    Of the Camp Chef and Traeger brands, one model stands out above the rest. The Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 Wood Pellet Grill is versatile, lightweight, and powerful. At just 22 lbs., and boasting 25,000 BTUs per hour, you can bring this pellet grill with you to any cookout, camping, or tailgating event. With a 22 lb. hopper capacity and 2 layers of grill top of maximum cooking space, you can whip up a great smokey-tasting grilled meal for all of your family and friends.


    Brand Comparisons

    If you’re in the market for a new pellet grill, you can’t go wrong with either of these tried-and-true brands. Both Camp Chef and Traeger have been making grills for a long time, and have the wealth of experience that comes with it.

    Each brand offers an array of products to suit any aspiring grill master. With impressive temperature ranges, digital controls, extra-large hoppers, and automatic augers, both brands know their way around a grill.

    Here’s a rundown on how each brand stacks up against the other.

    Temperature Range

    Both brands have impressive ranges when it comes to how low and how high they can go. Most of the offered products cook using an outstanding number of techniques, including braising, broiling, slow-cooking, or BBQing at high heat.

    Both have upward limits of 500°F, with Trager going as low as 165° and Camp Chef to 160°. These are standard for the industry; however, Camp Chef stands out in that this brand offers a Side Sear Box, which can hit upwards of 900°F. It’s a pricey extra, but it lets you sear pieces of meat to seal in moisture and add extra flavor.

    Temp Control

    Traeger’s lineup has many technological advances, from the more basic Digital Elite Controller, which is still pretty impressive, to the ultra-fancy WiFIRE system that lets you monitor and control the temp on your grill from your smartphone.

    Camp Chef doesn’t trumpet the more technical aspects of its grills’ controls, although this brand also sports Smart Smoke Technology. Camp Chef celebrates the precision at which their grills hold the temp. Camp Chef has a heat controller that can hold the internal temperature to within 10° of where it is set. They figure that their customer base favors simplicity and easy-to-use interfaces over the high tech gadgetry.

    Technological Aspects

    Along with temperature control devices, both brands share details like automatic augers, which supply a steady stream of pellets when needed. They also both carry models that come with meat prongs so you can check the internal temperature of whatever you’re cooking.

    Traeger revels in cutting-edge technology, and for those who embrace tech as well, this brand offers a slew of options. Camp Chef tends to stick to the idea that simpler is better. They have honed the cooking methods and ranges with their products, and maintain a consistently solid product.

    Hopper Size

    Both brands break about even with hopper size. The capacities of models from both Camp Chef and Traeger hold similar amounts of pellets – 18 to 20 lbs. – that will be sufficient for up to 12 hours of smoking meats.

    Some folks want a grill that you can adjust to within a degree and can oversee cooking straight from your Smartphone. Others simply want a grill that will be precise and simple.

    Both Traeger and Camp Chef have made impressive names for themselves in the grilling industry. Both offer the highest level of versatility when it comes to range of cooking methods and capacity. Depending on your needs and lifestyle, there’s sure to be a grill that will perfectly deliver wood-fired goodies for your family.