Battle of Grill Giants: Char Broil Vs Broil King

We hope you love the products we recommend. SeriouslySmoked.com may earn a commission on qualifying purchases from Amazon Associates or other vendors. Read more here.

Last Updated on February 18, 2021

A long-time contributor to SeriouslySmoked, has written widely about the world of barbecue and grilling.

Which is better?

Char-Broil and Broil King are two of the most famous names in the outdoor cooking industry. Providing BBQing enthusiasts with the leading-edge grill designs that consistently cook to perfection, both brands have loyal followings around the world.

The most suitable grill for you often comes down to personal preferences. Some people want a grill so they can throw large parties and entertain friends and family on the weekends. In this scenario, you’ll need a large grill, potentially dual-cooking areas, and an integrated warming rack.

For those who prefer to cook for a small household, a compact grill is adequate. If you like to grill every day, a quick-start feature on a gas grill can save a considerable amount of time over igniting a charcoal-fueled grill.

Grills are also an investment. You need to ensure your grill is made of durable materials such as stainless steel or aluminum and has heavy-duty grates that can withstand intense heat. Because it is a feature in your yard, the style and color may also be important considerations.

While there are several excellent models from these outdoor cooking equipment experts, for the best grill on the market, buy the Broil King Signet 320 Cast-Aluminum 3 Burner Liquid Propane Gas Grill.

Brand Overviews

When purchasing your grill, you can gain peace of mind by buying from trusted suppliers that have built their reputations over many years. The ever-expanding customer bases of Broil King and Char-Broil are a testament to their long-lasting and continued success.

As 2 of the most experienced brands in the market, Broil King and Char-Broil can help you to enjoy great grilling experiences.


Char-Broil Grills

Char-Broil is a leading innovator in bringing portable grills and gas grills with electric ignitions to the market. The first charcoal grill they sold to the US public was in 1948, so they have over 7 decades of experience creating high-quality, yet affordable, grills.

Char-Broil takes pride in the consistency of its outdoor cooking equipment and is an industry leader when it comes to developing new designs that provide dependable results.

The brand’s cooking system focuses on providing even heat distribution throughout the entire cooking surface. By avoiding cold spots and flare-ups, this feature provides a more reliable preparation of meats and vegetables.

Although these grills produce steady cooking results, Char-Broil understands there are different cooking needs, so it provides a wide and varied selection of grills. Whether you have a large or small backyard, or you want to take your grill away camping or to a tailgate party, Char-Broil has a grill for you.

Before you purchase your next grill, check out the outstanding options available from Char-Broil.


Broil King Grills

Broil King is a family-owned company that takes pride in using North American workers to build its grills using mostly North American parts. The brand uses locally-sourced steel to build many components, such as its cook boxes, carts, cabinets, and shelves.

Some of Broil King’s grills are large enough to cook in a commercial setting, whereas others are ideal for small meals for just a few people. Broil King has a grill for every need and to suit every budget.

Its renowned Flav-R-Wave cooking system cooks food thoroughly and maximizes the retention of juices and grilling flavors.  This feature helps to keep meat moist even when you are cooking on high heat. You also have instant and accurate temperature control over the heat in the cooking chamber, allowing you to cook meat to your preferred taste.

As the go-to brand for many outdoor cooking enthusiasts, consider the Broil King range before purchasing your next grill.


Top Char Broil and Broil King Grills For 2021

Our Top Choice...

Key Features

  • 400 sq.in. primary and 635 sq. in. total cooking area
  • Choose between liquid propane and gas fuel source
  • Powerful and steady 40,000 BTU output
  • Guaranteed quick-start heat ignition
  • Precision temperature control
  • Uses famous Flav-R-Wave cooking system

1. Best Overall - Broil King Signet 320 Cast-Aluminum 3 Burner Liquid Propane Gas Grill

Signet 320

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 2” x 23.2” x 48.4”
  • Weight: 134 lbs.
  • Choose between liquid propane and gas fuel source
  • Powerful and steady 40,000 BTU output

When the weather is sunny and you invite friends and family over for an impromptu cook-out, you don’t want to have problems lighting your grill. The Sure-Lite electronic ignition system on this model ensures you can ignite your grill quickly and easily every time. Once it is lit, the Flav-R-Wave cooking system spreads heat evenly over the cooking surface, helping you to cook food thoroughly and evenly.

Because there is a primary cooking surface area of a massive 400 sq. in. and a secondary area of 235 sq.in, it’s essential there are no cold spots or hot spots that could leave food undercooked or charred.

The reversible cast-iron cooking grates are excellent at retaining heat, allowing you to sear meat, sealing in the juices, and smoky grill flavors. Use the pointed side of the cooking grids to impress your guests by adding restaurant-grade steak sear marks to meat. If you want to maximize the moist, melt-in-your-mouth texture from your grill, then use the other side of the grids.

These hollow sides collect juices that flow out of the meat, so you can baste them back on to your food. This is ideal for preventing the drying out that can occur with some other rival grills.

Built from durable materials that can provide many years of great cooking experiences, and backed by a limited lifetime warranty, you can cook with confidence with this superb model.

Pros

Guaranteed quick-start heat ignition
400 sq.in. primary and 635 sq. in. total cooking area
Precision temperature control
Uses famous Flav-R-Wave cooking system
Back by a limited lifetime warranty

Cons

One of the more expensive grills on the market

2.  Best Runner Up - Broil King 921154 Baron 320 Gas Grill

921154 Baron 320

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 50” x 24” x 45.5”
  • Weight: 124 lbs.
  • Up to 30,000 BTUs
  • Available in stylish stainless steel or black color schemes

One of the most robust-feeling grills available, this model comes with resin leg levelers. These components are weather-resistant for long-lasting performance, and help you to stabilize your grill on uneven ground. While this is useful for safety, it also prevents meat from moving with gravity when cooking.

You can provide an extra layer of security by using the 4 locking casters to prevent the wheels from moving. With the legendary Performance Grilling Technology (PGT) system, you can cook a 3-course meal without leaving your grill.

The side burner is ideal for heating up soups and sauces, you can use the 2 cooking areas to prepare the main course, and you can even bake desserts.

For those who like to relax around the table and chat after an excellent meal, keep the side burner on a low temperature and heat up coffee or tea to finish off the night.

The dual-tube burners on the main cooking surfaces provide 2 rows of flames per burner, giving even heat distribution in the cooking chamber. The stainless steel cook box also helps to retain heat for a quicker cooking experience. The 180° Sensi-touch control allows you to choose your preferred cooking temperature.

For an extra-preparation area, or for somewhere to set your drink, use the convenient fold-down stainless steel side trays. They expand your workspace when you need it, and are compact for storage.

Pros

Dual-purpose cooking grills for improved results
Built-in side burner is ideal for heating soups and sauces
Integrated wheels for easy transportation
Even heat distribution across the cooking surface
Durable materials for increased lifespan

Cons

Cooking surface does not have a variable height adjustment feature

3.  Best Budget - Char-Broil Grill2Go X200 Portable TRU-Infrared Liquid Propane Gas Grill

Grill2Go X200 Portable

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 23.7” x 15” x 13.6”
  • Weight: 20 lbs.
  • 9,500-BTU heat production
  • Robust cooking grates

Shopping for a grill on a budget doesn’t mean accepting a drop in quality. The cast aluminum firebox and lid on this portable model are durable, and the stainless steel latches keep the lid closed during transportation.

The high-impact frame is ideal for withstanding the accidental bumps and scrapes that can occur during a weekend away in nature, or when tailgating with friends. After carrying it with the built-in carry arms, and finding a picturesque spot for your BBQ, you can use the integrated legs for stability. 

Even though this grill has a compact design, it has a spacious 200 sq.in. cooking space. By cooking off the ground, it also reduces the chance of accidentally starting a fire, and places the grill at a more comfortable height for cooking.

The TRU-infrared cooking system ensures that there are virtually no flare-ups. This feature helps to reduce the chances of burning meat on the outside. Aside from affecting the taste and texture, it could also give the appearance that meat is cooked, when the heat has not penetrated through to the middle.

You can easily adjust the temperature within the cooking chamber, and the built-in lid thermometer gives an accurate real-time reading, so you know if you need to turn the burners up or down. This model is compatible with 1 lb. propane tanks that are also light, which helps with transportation. When ready for use, you can easily attach a tank to the side of the grill, and use the push-button start feature for instant ignition.

Pros

TRU-infrared cooking system for even heat distribution
Easy to transport and set-up in any location
Generous cooking area despite the compact size
Perfect for trips away in nature
Made of durable materials

Cons

Only available in 1 color scheme

4. Best Durability - Char-Broil 463377319 Performance 4-Burner Grill

463377319 Performance 4-Burner

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 50.40” x 24.50” x 45”
  • Weight: 92.8 lbs.
  • Efficient and easy-to-clean stainless steel burners
  • Can supply up to 36,000 BTUs of heat to main grill

For a solid, robust model that also has a range of excellent features, this model checks a lot of boxes. The porcelain-coated cast-iron grates can last for many years, while also providing superb heat transference. The grid construction material can help to make meat juicier and moist by searing food when cooked, trapping the liquids within the food.

The social aspect of a cookout is just as important as the food. If you have meat ready but need to cook more for other guests, use the integrated warming rack to keep cooked meat heated.

When all the food is ready at the same time, you can use the side trays to hold plates while you dish out. These features are ideal when you want to have everyone sitting around the table at the same time. Because there is a powerful side burner, you can also heat up starters, such as soups and sauces that can accompany the main course.

This grill also has several aspects that make it convenient for regular use. The stainless steel surfaces are easy to wipe down with a damp cloth and weather-resistant.

While you need a grill cover to keep the unit in pristine condition for long-term use, it is resistant to both rust and corrosion. The intelligent grease removal system also allows you to dispose of any accumulated grease, and ensure it is ready for the next use.

Pros

Keep cooked food warm on the integrated warming rack
Side trays for preparing side dishes and vegetables
Porcelain-coated cast-iron grates
Convenient grease removal system
Robust, long-lasting model

Cons

Not as aesthetically pleasing as some rival models

5. Best Convenience - Broil King 911050 Keg 2000 Charcoal Barbecue Grill

911050 Keg 2000

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 5” x 27.5” x 45”
  • Weight: 115 lbs.
  • Convection-style cooking
  • Sturdy steel frame

This beautifully-crafted model allows you to cook a range of meals without ever leaving the grill. If you need to cook quickly, the high-performance lid seal prevents heat from escaping, and you can use the built-in lid thermometer to check the internal temperature. There is no need to raise the lid to allow heat to disappear.

If the temperature isn’t quite right, you can adjust the amount of oxygen that reaches the charcoal using the dampers. Turn the number settings up to increase the airflow, and therefore the temperature, or turn them down to bring the heat level down.

This is also an excellent safety feature, as you can fully close the damper after cooking, and the coals extinguish quickly because they do not receive more oxygen. If you are cooking for a group that has varied tastes, you can use this grill to cook meat, vegetables, pizza, and even bake a dessert.

There is a convenient basket below the grill where you can store your cooking utensils, and there are useful side handles for moving the grill to the sunniest spot in the yard.

Although this is a relatively heavy model, it also comes with wheels so you do not have to lift the grill off the ground. This model has a durable powder-coated finish that is rust- and corrosion-resistant, so you can be sure it is built to last for many years. A handy feature is the bottle opener that is built into the lid handle, so you don’t have to spend time trying to chase yours down.

Pros

Integrated dampers to control airflow
Built-in lid thermometer
High-performance lid seal
Durable powder-coated finish
Bottle opener on the lid

Cons

Heavier than many rival models

6. Best Versatility - Char-Broil The Big Easy TRU-Infrared Smoker Roaster & Grill

The Big Easy TRU-Infrared

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 1” x 23.4” x 36.2”
  • Weight: 22.7 lbs.
  • Built-in side-mounted carry handles
  • Uses propane tank for fuel source

If you enjoy cooking large cuts of meat, this grill could be the right choice for you. While there is a 180 sq. in. cooking area for steaks and other fine cuts, you can also use the integrated roasting basket to cook larger chunks of meat.

For finishing off meat and sealing in the moisture and juices, you can even start the cooking process in the basket, slice it into slimmer pieces, and then finish it off on the grill. This feature is ideal if you are cooking for a large group of people.

Use the stainless steel smoker box that is on the outside of the grill to add wood chips without needing to lift the lid. Choose your favorite grilling smell, and allow it to infuse into the meat.

The famous Char-Broil TRU-infrared cooking system distributes heat evenly throughout the cooking surfaces, ensuring that both finely-cut and chunkier pieces of meat are thoroughly cooked through. You can also easily adjust the temperature between 9,000 and 18,000 BTUs for precision control of the heat level.

The 4 sturdy legs provide excellent stability, and the long hose pipe means you can set the fuel tank nearby, without needing to attach it to the frame of the grill. Because this model utilizes a one-touch ignition system, it is easy to start. For a model that mixes a superb blend of versatility and functionality, this is a solid choice.

Pros

Grill, smoke, and roast on one grill
Even heat distribution for improved cooking results
Efficient temperature control system
Straightforward one-touch ignition system
Convenient side-mounted smoker box

Cons

May be larger than many people require

Final Verdict

Signet 320

When it comes to choosing between a Broil King grill and a Char-Broil grill, it can be challenging. Both brands create fantastic grills that come with many excellent features. While the competition is close, there is one that stands above its rivals.

With a quick-start ignition system that guarantees to light every time, and precision temperature control that allows you to fine-tune the internal heat chamber, you can cook meat to your taste. The high-quality cooking grids retain heat so you can sear the juices and flavors into your meats, and the cooking surface is spacious enough when cooking for large groups.

Coming with a limited lifetime warranty, you can cook with confidence, knowing the manufacturer stands with its product.

If you’re ready to buy a grill that has all the features you need for a great outdoor grilling experience, you are ready to buy the Broil King Signet 320 Cast-Aluminum 3 Burner Liquid Propane Gas Grill.


Brand Comparison

Choosing between models and brands is challenging. However, you can narrow down your choices by considering the unique features of each grill.

Depending on the size of your backyard, how much control you need over the heat of your grill, and even the size of the preparation areas for preparing accompanying dishes, you may favor one grill over another. Fortunately, many grills have a range of high-quality features.

Cooking Space

Whether you need lots of cooking space or you are happy with a smaller grill, this is a crucial factor. The Broil King Signet 320 Cast-Aluminum 3 Burner Liquid Propane Gas Grill is ideal for those who like to cook for a lot of people.

With 400 sq. in. of primary cooking area, and a further 235 sq. in. of secondary space, this grill is spacious enough to cook for large groups. It is ideal for parties and special occasions when friends and family gather together.

However, if you only need to cook for yourself, or for a small household, then the Char-Broil Grill2Go X200 Portable TRU-Infrared Liquid Propane Gas Grill is a great choice.

The 200 sq. in. cooking area is large enough to hold several steaks, burgers, or pieces of chicken at the same time, while it is also compact and doesn’t take up too much space in the backyard.

Temperature Control

Cooking meat to perfection requires having precise control over the grill temperature. The Broil King 921154 Baron 320 Gas Grill’s 180° Sensi-Touch control allows you to adjust the internal heat level with fine precision.

You won’t have a problem with the ignition because the burners respond instantly to each turn of the control knob, you can quickly reduce the heat to avoid the risk of overcooking meat, and gently raise the temperature to cook your meal through to the middle.

The Char-Broil The Big Easy TRU-Infrared Smoker Roaster & Grill also offers superior temperature control. The adjustment range of between 9,000 BTUs and 18,000 BTUs is impressive, and the TRU-infrared heating system ensures the heat evenly distributes across the entire cooking surface.

Preparation Surface Area

The preparation area is an extension of the cooking surface area, because you can marinate meat, cut and prepare vegetables, keep seasonings handy, and it’s also ideal for somewhere to place your drink.

The Broil King Signet 320 Cast-Aluminum 3 Burner Liquid Propane Gas Grill has 2 side tables that provide ample preparation area even for large cookouts. Made of stainless steel, they can also withstand extreme weather conditions, can accommodate hot plates without tarnishing the surface, and are easy to clean.

It’s inevitable when handling juicy meats and delicious sauces that there are some spills, so it’s important that cleaning up a spill doesn’t take away from the enjoyment of cooking outdoors.

The Char-Broil 463377319 Performance 4-Burner Grill also comes with 2 side tables. However, it also integrates a powerful side burner that sits under a secure lid. When heating up soups or other sides, you can raise the covering, and the burner is easily accessible. While this is convenient, it also helps to save space.

Related: Both Char-Broil and Broil King are hot brands to buy. We made adjoining review pages for the 2 brands below:

Author: Jim Bob

Jim's a long-time contributor to SeriouslySmoked, has written widely about the world of barbecue, grilling and outdoor living.

jim bob