Weber vs Broil King Grills Reviews

We hope you love the products we recommend. SeriouslySmoked.com may earn a commission on qualifying purchases from Amazon Associates or other vendors. Read more here.

Last Updated on February 19, 2021

A long-time contributor to SeriouslySmoked, has written widely about the world of barbecue and grilling.

comparison

BBQ enthusiasts have been enjoying Weber and Broil King grills for many years. As innovators and leaders in the outdoor cooking industry, they consistently produce well-crafted, attractive, and efficient grills.

Choosing a grill often comes down to individual preference. You may value a quick-start feature over a one-touch cleaning system. Perhaps you value a large cooking surface more than even heat distribution. 

However, with the advent of new technologies, and the benefit of many years of experience, these grilling giants are now producing grills that can do it all. Deciding which grill to purchase continues to become more challenging, and it may be the size of your yard or your budget that are the deciding factors. 

With the range of available color schemes, it may even be the appearance of a grill that directs your choice. Because you can expect consistent results from any Weber or Broil King grill, you may now choose to focus more on the extras, such as accessory hooks, side burners, warming racks, and side trays.

There are several grills that represent excellent value for money and have a host of amazing outdoor cooking features. However, for the best grill on the market, choose the Broil King Signet 320 Cast-Aluminum 3 Burner Liquid Propane Gas Grill.

Brand Overviews

As two of the leading brands in outdoor cooking, Weber and Broil King have decades of experience providing the highest-quality grills to BBQing enthusiasts around the world. Their reputations precede them, and each has their unique take on how to design the best grills on the market.

Weber Grills

The founder of Weber, George Stephenson, designed the iconic kettle grill in 1952. Although it remains one of the most popular grills available, the company has expanded its product range. Whether you need cooking utensils, brushes, drip pans, BBQ fuel, or any grilling accessory, it’s likely you can buy it at Weber. 

Although their range is diverse, they are most famous for their well-built and innovative grills, and they continue to lead the industry by building on their experience and customer feedback.

While Weber provides luxury grills that are at the higher end of the price range, they also have many options that are affordable on any budget. As every Weber grill meets exacting standards, even the more affordable models are packed with great features that delight their ever-growing customer base.

Some of the most attractive aspects of Weber grills are the even heat distribution across the cooking surface, cast-iron cooking grates, built-in lid thermometers, and integrated warming racks.

When it comes to choosing your next grill, it’s essential to browse the Weber range before making a purchase.


Broil King Grills

Broil King takes pride in using skilled North American workers to build their grills, and they also purchase as many of the materials as possible from North American suppliers. This philosophy forms a strong part of their identity, and they are also proud to be a family-owned company. 

There is a Broil King grill for every need, from large grills that can fit into a commercial environment, right down to individual units that are suitable for cooking for one person. Although they also produce excellent smokers, their incredible array of grills confirms that they are their primary focus

The Broil King customer service experience is top-notch, and they have included fantastic features throughout their product range. The Flav-R-Wave cooking system ensures your food is cooked thoroughly while maximizing moisture retention, and the precision temperature control allows you to raise and lower the internal heat level within moments.  with their stylish appearance, Broil King grills are the go-to choice for many grillers.

As one of the best manufacturers in the market, Broil King has a grill that is ideal for your outdoor cooking needs.


Weber VS Broil King Grills - 2021 Reviews

Our Top Choice...

Key Features

  • Up to 40,000 BTU output
  • Suitable for use with natural gas or liquid propane
  • Sure-Lite electronic ignition system
  • Limited lifetime warranty

1. Best Overall - Broil King Signet 320 Cast-Aluminum 3 Burner Liquid Propane Gas Grill

Signet

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 62.2” x 23.2” x 48.4”
  • Weight: 134 lbs.
  • Up to 40,000 BTU output
  • Suitable for use with natural gas or liquid propane

The Sure-Lite electronic ignition system ensures your grill starts quickly every time, and the patented dual-tube burners distribute heat evenly over the cooking surface. This feature is essential for ensuring there are no cold spots on your grill that could undercook food and no particular hot spots that may overcook and ruin your meal.  

The cast-iron grids maximize heat retention and also enable you to sear meat to keep in the juices and flavors. They also help to keep meat moist and avoid the drying out of food that can occur with some rival models. 

Because there is a generous 635 sq. in. of cooking area, you can cook for a large group of family and friends, and have all the food ready at the same time. Use the linear-flow burner valves to precisely control the temperature, which is ideal when you need to time your grilled meat to be ready at the same time as other sides being prepared in the kitchen.

There is an integrated powerful side burner that can warm sauces and soups to accompany your meat, and there’s even a built-in rotisserie burner that comes with a premium-grade spot rod and reliable motor. The burners produce a consistent cooking heat all the way through your food, for mouth-watering results.

For all your accessories, and a convenient place to set your drink, use the fold-down shelves. After use, simply release them back to their resting position for easy storage.

Pros

  • Sure-Lite electronic ignition system
  • 635 sq. in. total cooking area
  • Linear-Flow burner valves for temperature control
  • Flav-R-Wave cooking system
  • Limited lifetime warranty

Cons

  • Excellent quality, but at the higher end of the price range

2. Runner Up - Weber 44010001 Spirit II E-210 2-Burner Liquid Propane Grill

Spirit II E-210

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 48” x 26” x 57”
  • Weight: 103 lbs.
  • Works with standard 20 lb. liquid propane tank
  • Open cart design

Take advantage of the compact design of this model and use the wheels to place it in the sunniest position in your backyard. The powerful G4S grilling system comprises 4 key elements to give you the best cooking results each and every time. 

The infinity ignition is guaranteed to instantly light the 2 fuel-efficient burners, and the flavorizer bars provide consistent gas flow to infuse your food with that outdoor smokey, delicious taste, and smell. The grease management system helps to avoid flare-ups and makes cleaning a straightforward experience. 

Flare-ups can cause some parts of your food to char, but any grease that is not vaporized by the porcelain-enameled grate bars slides away from the burners. The grease goes into a drip tray located underneath the cook box. You can easily take the drip tray away, and replace it with another, reducing the need for heavy-duty cleaning materials.

Once you’ve cooked your meats to your taste, you can use the included warming rack to keep it ready for serving while you wait for the vegetables to cook or vice versa. This feature is also ideal for warming burger or hot dog buns in preparation for serving.

When adding a gas tank, you can fit it on the outside of the grill for easy access. There is a built-in fuel gauge so you can check if you need to attach a fresh tank, ideal for ensuring you don’t run out of gas just when your guests are getting hungry.

Pros

  • Porcelain-enameled, cast-iron cooking grates
  • Built-in lid thermometer
  • Fuel gauge so you know when to top-up
  • Wheels for easy maneuverability
  • Powerful GS4 grilling system

Cons

  • Only available in black or mocha color schemes

3. Best Budget - Weber Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill, 22-Inch

Original Kettle Premium

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 39.5” x 22.5” x 27”
  • Weight: 32.3 lbs.
  • 3D interactive assembly instructions through the free app
  • High-capacity ash catcher

If you’re shopping for a grill while on a budget, there’s no need to accept a reduction in quality. This feature-packed model uses Weber’s famous kettlebell design to make outdoor cooking an enjoyable and hassle-free experience. The durable lid and bowl have a porcelain-enameled covering, which helps to retain heat. 

While this feature is essential for ensuring you can cook food thoroughly, it also saves money because you need to use less fuel. For your convenience, there is a lid hook so you don’t need to put the lid on the ground during grilling. Also, the hinged cooking grate gives easy access to the charcoal pit, so you can refill the coals even when you’re already grilling.

Although this is one of the smaller and lighter grills on the market, it can hold an impressive 13 burgers at one time. If you need to adjust the heat to cook your meat faster, you can open the dampers to increase the airflow to the charcoal. If food is cooking too quickly, close them slightly and less oxygen reaches the coals. 

The dampers are also an excellent safety feature. When you’re finished cooking, fully close them and the fuel is starved of oxygen and extinguishes more rapidly. When it’s time to clean up, you can use the one-touch cleaning system and removable ash pan. 

While this model is considerably more affordable than many rivals, it has a wide range of features that you would expect on more expensive models. It’s a solid choice for those shopping on a budget.

Pros

  • Holds up to 13 burgers
  • Hinged cooking grate for easily adding charcoal
  • Porcelain-enameled lid and bowl
  • One-touch cleaning system
  • Easily-accessible accessory hooks

Cons

  • Doesn’t feel as solid as some rival models

4. Best Versatility - Broil King 921154 Baron 320 Gas Grill

baron

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 50” x 24” x 45.5”
  • Weight: 124 lbs.
  • 4 locking casters for stability
  • Comes in black or stainless steel color schemes

If you like to experiment when outdoor cooking, this could be the model for you. You can cook steaks on the grill, use the rotisserie for beautifully prepared chicken, and even bake desserts to complete your meal. 

The reversible cast-iron cooking grids are pointed on one side for professional-looking sear marks when cooking meat, and the other side has grooves. These hollows collect the juices that seep out of moist meat, so you can collect them and baste your food for maximum flavor.

If you want to heat up starters or side dishes while still cooking your main course, there’s no need to leave the grill unattended. Use the side burner to perfectly prepare soups and sauces. You can even turn on the side burner after your meal to heat up relaxing drinks such as a hot brandy or port.

There is a 180° Sensi-Touch control that allows you to finely adjust the temperature to your desired level. The dual burners respond instantly to your instructions, which can be crucial if you notice the meat is beginning to overcook. 

It’s also ideal if you want to gently warm food just before serving. Because the burners are covered by a 10-year warranty, you can cook with confidence, knowing the manufacturer can replace them in the unlikely event that a fault should occur.

There are a variety of options with this model, and you can choose between 3, 4, and 5 burners, and if you prefer natural gas or liquid propane as a fuel source.

Pros

  • Reversible heavy-duty cast-iron cooking grids
  • Produces up to 30,000 BTUs
  • Uses Performance Grilling Technology (PGT)
  • Durable cook box increases heat retention
  • Comes with integrated side burner

Cons

  • Heavy compared to some rival models

Final Verdict

Signet

Weber and Broil King have years of experience in the outdoor cooking industry and use it to innovate and design the latest in grilling technology. While every grill is high-quality and contributes to a great grilling experience, there is one that currently has the edge over its rivals.

With a generous combined cooking surface of 635 sq. in., and a side burner that is ideal for heating up sauces to accompany your main course, you can cook a full meal without leaving your grill. 

You can cook for many years using this grill because it is made of durable materials. The therma-cast aluminum cook box and stainless steel insert help to retain heat and can withstand intense temperatures even during extended cookouts.

It also brings convenience with the Sure-Lite electronic starting system, a consistent cooking experience with the linear-flow burner valves, and helps to seal in the juices and flavors that make your meat so tasty through the Flav-R-Wave cooking system. If you want to know what a grill can do, this model checks the boxes for just about every outdoor cooking requirement.

For an unrivaled range of features, get the best outdoor cooking grill on the market and buy the Broil King Signet 320 Cast-Aluminum 3 Burner Liquid Propane Gas Grill.


Brand Comparison

When 2 world-renowned brands produce models that are consistently high-quality, reliable, and efficient, it can be challenging to choose between brands as well as models. 

Because every BBQ enthusiast has their unique preferences, comparing the individual features is an effective way to narrow down your choice.

Temperature Control

Temperature control is key when cooking meat to perfection. The Weber Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill has a straightforward system that involves adjusting the dampers to control the flow of oxygen to the charcoal. However, judging the right amount of airflow required to produce a specific temperature of decrease is challenging. 

In comparison, the Broil King Signet 320 Cast-Aluminum grill has a 180° Sensi-Touch control that allows you to instantly adjust the heat level. While both systems can give you the desired results, the Broil King system gives a greater degree of control and accuracy. 

Cleaning Systems

The Broil King 921154 Baron 320 Liquid Propane Gas Grill uses high-quality materials that are easy to wipe down. Using a damp cloth on the cast-iron cooking grids and the fold-away side trays keep them in pristine condition and prevent the accumulation of grime while also stopping rusting.

However, the Weber Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill uses an efficient one-touch cleaning system that takes the hassle out of cleaning your grill after cooking. If you choose the Weber 44010001 Spirit II E-210 2-Burner Liquid Propane Grill, the grease management system makes draining and disposal an easy task.

Convenience of Use

When you’re cooking outdoors, convenience is crucial. Grilling is a social event. While both Weber and Broil King have instant-start systems on their gas-powered grills, and even the charcoal versions are easy to light and stoke, the crucial difference can be when it comes to accessories. 

If you have everything you need on-hand when cooking, then you can enjoy relaxing with family and friends while standing around the grill. 

The Broil King 921154 Baron 320 Liquid Propane Gas Grill has handy fold-away side trays that allow you to keep seasonings, tongs, and plates within reach, and this is matched by the Weber 44010001 Spirit II E-210 2-Burner Liquid Propane Grill. 

The Weber Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill does not have side tables which makes it less convenient for preparing food and storing tools. 

However, it does provide hinged grates and a lid holder that allow you to add charcoal during grilling, and there is no need to put the lid on the ground when cooking. Depending on your cooking needs, both are good options.

Cooking Surface Area

With a primary cooking area of 400 sq. in. and a total cooking surface area of 635 sq. in., the Broil King Signet 320 Cast Aluminum grill is a great choice if you plan on cooking for large groups. 

However, if you’re cooking for your household or smaller groups, the Weber Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill should be large enough for your needs. Because both are easy to light and to clean, you can even use them for everyday cooking.


Did you learn something with our Weber vs Broil King review? It's always good to compare one product to another so that you’ll know what features standout. To further analyze the features that Weber grills can bring, we also made adjoining comparison reviews that you may be interested: