Weber VS Char Broil Grills Reviews

We hope you love the products we recommend. SeriouslySmoked.com may earn a commission on qualifying purchases from Amazon Associates or other vendors. Read more here.

Last Updated on February 19, 2021

A long-time contributor to SeriouslySmoked, has written widely about the world of barbecue and grilling.

Comparison

Weber and Char-Broil have been delighting BBQing enthusiasts with their excellent quality, yet affordable, grills for many years. As industry leaders, they are responsible for innovative designs that improve the cooking experience, while also building grills that are durable and provide many years of reliable service.

Although there are some grills that are more sophisticated than their rivals, choosing a grill is a personal choice, and comes down to your individual requirements. If you cook for yourself or a small household, a compact model with a reduced cooking surface may be ideal. 

If you often throw parties or invite the neighbors over for a BBQ, you’ll need a large grill and a complementary preparation area. Budget is an important factor in your choice, and you also want to know that your grill is reliable. 

If you like to cook every day on your grill, a quick-start option is essential, and many offer convenient storage options where you can keep fuel and seasonings for use when cooking. Easy cleaning is also vital for outdoor cooking because no one wants to spend unnecessary time wiping down hard-to-clean materials.

Whatever your requirements, there is a grill that can help make outdoor cooking an immensely enjoyable experience. If you’re ready to purchase the best on the market, then choose the Char-Broil 463377319 Performance 4-Burner Grill.

Brand Overviews

While there are several excellent grill manufacturers in the market, few have the sterling reputations of Weber and Char-Broil. Those who love outdoor cooking are aware that reliability and the ability to prepare food to the requirements of every guest are crucial. 

As two of the best suppliers in the market, you can trust Weber and Char-Broil to help you prepare the perfect BBQ every time.

Weber

A well-known name in the grilling world, Weber’s founder, George Stephen, produced his first kettlebell-shaped grill in 1952. The company has since instilled the values of quality craftsmanship, quality materials, and value for money in every product it produces. 

While Weber has expanded its range of grilling products to include smokers, drip pans, chimney starters, cleaning kits, premium tools sets, and many other accessories, its grills are still the focus of much of the company’s attention.

You can purchase charcoal, propane gas, and electric grills, and you can choose between portable options or grills that are a feature in your yard. While there are top-of-the-range grills that can be quite expensive, there are also plenty of choices for those shopping on a budget.

With great features such as built-in lid thermometers, warming racks, and LCD timers, Weber has grills that can suit the requirements of any grill master.

When choosing a grill, don’t make a purchase before you check out the incredible array of grills made by Weber.


Char-Broil

After producing one of the first charcoal grills in the US in 1948, Char-Broil has continuously improved its grill designs. Over the subsequent decades, it has continued to provide affordable grills that improve cookouts for expert grillers. 

As an industry leader, Char-Broil was one of the first to manufacture gas grills with electric ignitions, electric grills, and portable grills. It takes pride in being an industry leader and in the consistency of results that its grills provide. You can expect to get the same results time after time with a Char-Broil Grill.

Char-Broil focuses on even heat distribution and zero flame flare-ups, producing tasty and juicy food for your family and friends. The brand appreciates that every backyard is different, and its outstanding selection of grills can meet a wide variety of cooking needs. Whether you’re at home or on a trip, these grills can deliver great food every time.

Char-Broil is one of the most trusted names in the industry, so check them out before buying another grill.


Weber VS Char Broil Grills - 2021 Reviews

Our Top Choice...

Key Features

  • 425-square inch cooking area
  • Stainless steel burners
  • 2 stainless steel side trays
  • 150 square inch Swing-away warming rack
  • Sleek and stylish design
  • Porcelain-coated cast-iron grates

1. Best Overall - Char-Broil Performance 4-Burner Gas Grill

Performance 4-Burner

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 50.40” x 24.50” x 45”
  • Weight: 92.8 lbs.
  • Stainless steel burners
  • Produces 36,000 BTUs of heat

The sleek and stylish design of this grill can be a talking point when inviting friends over for a BBQ, and the stainless steel finish ensures that it can provide many years of rust- and corrosion-resistant use. 

While the 4 burners and 425-square inch cooking area provide plenty of power and heating space, this is complemented by the swing-away warming rack. Part of the enjoyment of outdoor grilling is everyone sitting down together to eat, and the warming rack lets you keep food heated while you put more meat on to cook.

Keep plates, tongs, and other handy items nearby using the 2 stainless steel side trays. When cooking at high temperatures, the porcelain-coated cast-iron grates can withstand long-term and intense use, and they also maximize heat transference. 

This feature is ideal for searing meat, sealing in the juices, and making food even tastier. The porcelain coating also stops food and seasonings from sticking to its surface. By wiping them down after each use, they stay clean and ready for the next cooking session,

If you love cooking in the sun, move the grill to the brightest spot in your yard by using the 2 7-inch wheels. Although the BBQ is substantial in size, the lightweight steel material means it is easy to maneuver. 

When it’s time to clean up, the removable grease tray and pan allow you to take them directly to a sink, and wipe them down with a damp cloth before the grease and ash can stick to the surface.

Pros

  • Swing-away warming rack
  • 2 stainless steel side trays
  • Porcelain-coated cast-iron grates
  • Removable grease tray and pan
  • Sleek and stylish design

Cons

  • One of the more expensive models on the market

2. Runner Up - Weber Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill

Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 43.5″ x 48″ x 30″
  • Weight: 91 lbs.
  • Uses reliable propane fuel 
  • Easy cleaning system for reduced hassle after cooking 
  • Available in 3 vibrant colors

Convenience is vital when you’re cooking outside, and the Charbin storage container allows you to access your fuel when you need it, without leaving your grill. Just keep it filled so it’s always ready for the next cookout. 

After placing a layer of charcoal in your BBQ, use the Touch N’ Go ignition system to instantly start your grill. Instead of letting heat out while you use an external thermometer or check the appearance of your grill, look at the built-in lid thermometer. 

This feature enables you to keep the accumulated heat in, while also giving you an accurate reading of the internal temperature. Open the dampers to further increase the flow of oxygen to raise the temperature, and close them slightly to lower the heat level. 

The dampers are an excellent way to control the amount of heat that reaches your food. When it’s time to extinguish the charcoal, close them completely for a safe and effective way of cutting off the oxygen supply

If you’re cooking for a group, the large work table allows you to keep all the seasonings, tools, and plates you need. This is ideal for saving time because you don’t need to go back and forth to the kitchen, and it also keeps the conversation flowing since you can stay around the grill with your guests.

Pros

  • Quick-start gas ignition system for easy lighting
  • Built-in lid thermometer so you can keep the heat in
  • Large workstation when preparing food for a group
  • Charbin storage container keeps fuel source at hand
  • Precision temperature control for rapid adjustments and reliable heating

Cons

  • Grill height is not variable

3. Best Budget - Char-Broil Grill2Go X200 Portable TRU-Infrared Liquid Propane Gas Grill

Grill2Go X200 Portable TRU-Infrared Liquid Propane Gas Grill

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 23.7” x 15” x 13.6”
  • Weight: 20 lbs.
  • 9,500-BTU main burner
  • Durable stainless steel grilling grate

If you’re looking for a grill that is at the lower end of the price range, this portable model from Char-Broil is an excellent choice. While you can use the compact design to load it into your RV and head out for the weekend, it also has a generous 200-square-inch cooking surface

The integrated carry handles enable you to easily carry the grill to your preferred cooking spot, and you can use the built-in legs to provide a solid and stable platform. The legs also keep the bottom of the grill from touching any grass, reducing the chances of leaving scorch marks.

The TRU-infrared cooking system provides a minimum of 65% infrared heat, rather than the convective heat used by other grills. The system then spreads this heat evenly across the cooking surface. This increased balance of heat enables you to cook food through, without drying, keeping the juices and taste inside the meat. 

One of the causes of cold spots in food, or overdone meat, is flare-ups in the cooking surface that can affect the temperature in one part of the grill. The TRU-infrared system virtually eliminates this effect.

The cast aluminum firebox and lid are durable, and are ideal for a weekend away camping when there could be some rough handling. The stainless steel latches ensure the lid stays firmly shut when in transit. This feature is also important for after use because it can reduce the smells from the grill that could attract unwanted attention from nearby wildlife.

Pros

  • TRU-infrared cooking system
  • Included legs and carry handles
  • 200-square-inch cooking area
  • Ideal for tailgating and camping

Cons

  • Only available in a gray color scheme

4. Best Portable - Weber Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill

Q1200

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 15.5” x 40.9” x 16.5”
  • Weight: 26 lbs.
  • Stainless steel burners for durability
  • Catch pan slides out for easy cleaning

This portable grill may not have the substantial cooking area of some rivals, but it makes up for this through a range of superb features that make it ideal for cooking at home or on a trip. Bumps and scrapes are almost inevitable when traveling, and the strong nylon frame is supported by a glass-reinforcement protection system. 

To complement a strong structure, the lid and body are made of aluminum that won’t lose color or suffer surface wear-and-tear as easily as some less-durable metals. Choose from 6 color schemes to add a touch of style to your grill. 

While the compact design is ideal for traveling and storage, the folding side tables increase the surface area for food preparation. The 8,500 BTUs per hour provides plenty of heat for cooking, while the cast-iron cooking grates can withstand many hours of intense use.

Although this grill isn’t suitable for cooking for a large party who wants to eat at the same time, you can easily cook for a small group at a cookout. It’s perfect for tailgating or beach parties when multiple people bring grills for a party atmosphere.

Choose between disposable 14.1 oz. or 16.4 oz. size LP cylinders, depending on your available cooking requirements. If you plan on cooking for a larger group, the larger cylinder means you won’t need to worry about constant propane tank refills. Because this grill comes fully-assembled, you can start using it as soon as it arrives at your home.

Pros

  • Nylon frame has robust glass reinforced support
  • Robust aluminum lid and body
  • Choose from 6 bright colors
  • Folding side tables for convenient access to cooking accessories
  • Fully-assembled right out of the box

Cons

  • Unsuitable for cooking for large parties

Final Verdict

Performance 4-Burner

Investing in a grill can give you many enjoyable experiences of outdoor cooking with your family and friends over the years. Choosing the most suitable, high-quality, and durable grill for your cooking needs means you need to consider Weber and Char-Broil grills

As market leaders in the BBQing industry, they provide reliable grills time after time, and you can be sure you’re getting the value for your money.

While there are several excellent choices, there is one model that checks nearly every box for the grilling enthusiast. The stylish design can be a talking point and the steel side trays provide plenty of space for keeping cooking essentials close at hand.


Brand Comparisons

When choosing between a Weber and Char-Broil grill, it can be challenging to make a decision. Both manufacturers produce high-quality and efficient grills that are enjoyable to use. 

However, each BBQ enthusiast has their individual requirements and preferences, so you can use the specifications of each grill to help narrow down your choices.

Grill Assembly

Before you can cook on your new grill, you need to assemble it. While portable grills often come fully-assembled, this is due to their size. However, larger grills, such as those that are for your backyard, usually require tools and patience to build. 

While the instructions for putting together the Char-Broil 463377319 Performance 4-Burner grill are straightforward, Weber is ahead in this category. 

It can help to visualize the grill and its component parts as they should look when they connect together, and Weber provides an app to take the guesswork away. 

They use intelligent 3D modeling to show you precisely how your grill should look during each stage of assembly. Even if you find DIY assembly challenging, this app can help you to build your grill quickly and easily.

Temperature Control

When cooking for multiple people, it’s likely they’ll ask you to cook their food to a variety of preferences. Temperature control is crucial and this is one aspect where the Char-Broil 463377319 Performance 4-Burner has the advantage. 

You can adjust each one of their 4 burners independently, so you can have a different temperature at each part of the grill. This feature is ideal when you’re preparing cuts of meat to be ready at the same time, even if you are cooking them to different specifications. 

While Weber also allows you to adjust the temperature, it is through the adjustment of dampers. By controlling the flow of air through the dampers, you can increase or decrease the internal heat level. However, adjusting airflow to find precise temperature ranges can be difficult, and it is easy to make the temperature too high or too low. 

On the portable grills, the Char-Broil Grill2Go X200 also comes out ahead of the Weber 51040001 Q1200. The even heat distribution from the TRU-infrared cooking system provides more control over the temperature in each area of the grill.

Cooking Surface

If you need a grill just to cook for yourself or a small household, a portable size grill may be all you need. If you like to invite friends over for parties, a larger cooking area enables you to cook for everyone at the same time.

While there may seem to be little difference between the 363-square-inch grilling area on the Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill, and the 425-square-inch cooking area on the Char-Broil 463377319 Performance 4-Burner, is significant if you are cooking for 6 or more people.

However, an extension of the cooking surface is the preparation area. The Weber grill uses one long surface, whereas the Char-Broil grill has one tray on either side of the cooking area. Weber’s version is easier to use and allows you to have all your plates, seasonings, and cutlery beside each other.


Did you learn something new about Weber or Char Broil? Both Weber and Char Broil are well-known product, and no doubt that they have many competitors. We also wanted to know how the 2 brands fair with other great products that’s why we made these other review: