Weber VS Dyna Glo: Your Complete Comparison Guide

We hope you love the products we recommend. SeriouslySmoked.com may earn a commission on qualifying purchases from Amazon Associates or other vendors. Read more here.

Last Updated on February 25, 2021

A long-time contributor to SeriouslySmoked, has written widely about the world of barbecue and grilling.

Comparison

When you are choosing a high-quality, yet affordable grill, it’s inevitable that Weber and Dyna Glo rise to the top of the list. Both brands are industry leaders and have been supplying innovative, reliable, and durable grills to BBQ enthusiasts for decades.  

While it is possible to pick a model that checks more boxes than other rivals, the reality is there are several excellent grills, and the right one for you comes down to your unique requirements.

If you often throw parties and cook for the neighborhood, your teen’s sports team, or your church congregation then you’ll value a large cooking area. However, if you like to make your food both at home and away on trips, then you may want to sacrifice the workspace for portability.

Reliable performance is crucial, so you know how your food cooks each and every time, and you’ll want to get value for money from a grill that can last for many years. Because grills spend a lot of time outside, it’s important they are corrosion-resistant.

While there are a number of excellent options, for the best outdoor grill on the market, choose the Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill.

Brand Overviews

The grill market has some excellent suppliers who have been serving up great products for many years. However, there are few manufacturers that can challenge the Weber and Dyna Glo brands, which are well-known and trusted by BBQ enthusiasts all around the world. Both have earned their reputation through consistently providing market-leading grills time and time again.


Weber Grills

Weber has a long history of making exceptional grills for demanding outdoor cooking enthusiasts. In fact, founder George Stephen made his first kettle grill in 1952. They have since expanded their product range to include propane gas grills, smokers, electric grills and portable grills, and just about every accessory you can imagine when it comes to BBQing. 

The staggering number of grills come in a variety of price-points. Whether you choose a top-of-the-range option or a more wallet-friendly grill, you always receive a product that is high-quality and can give you many years of excellent service.

Some of Weber grills’ most attractive features are built-in thermometers, hinged grates, removable ash-catcher pans, warming racks, large surface areas for food preparation, and the variable vibrant color schemes. 

Although they are best known for their signature kettlebell design, they also provide a range of other grills that can fit any size patio and that cook for just a few people or large groups. 

When choosing your grill, research Weber grills before purchasing another make or model.


Dyna Glo

Dyna Glo offers around 15 different propane grills and another 3 for natural gas. All their grills come with a 5-year warranty for their burners, which speaks volumes for their confidence in their build quality. There is also a 1-year warranty for all other parts of the grill, ensuring you can cook with confidence. 

While they come with a mid-range price tag, they offer a superior build quality to many rivals. They are also easy to assemble, which is ideal if you’re not a DIY enthusiast, or just want to get cooking as quickly as possible.

Dyna Glo grills have a range of excellent features, so you can choose the one that best suits your needs. Ones to look out for are the easy one-touch lighting buttons, double-walled stainless steel lids that offer maximum heat retention, massive cooking surfaces that are big enough to prepare food for lots of people simultaneously, and handy shelves and hanging hooks for your tools and accessories.

For a grill that provides a high-quality cooking experience without breaking the bank, consider Dyna Glo.


Weber VS Dyna Glo Grills - 2020 Reviews

1. Best Overall - Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill

Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 43.5″ x 48″ x 30″ 
  • Weight: 91 lbs.
  • Available in 3 attractive color schemes
  • One-touch cleaning system for convenience after use
  • Can use 2 sizes of propane tanks

When you come home from work and the weather is ideal for outdoor cooking, the last thing you need is to have trouble lighting the grill. With their intelligent electronic Touch-N-Go ignition system, Weber guarantees a quick start from their deluxe charcoal grill. At the push of a button, it instantly lights and starts heating the coals.

The Charbin storage container provides a convenient storage container that enables quick access to your fuel supply, and also keeps it dry during wet weather. Say goodbye to carrying heavy bags of charcoal from your garage every time you want to light your grill.  

There is a large work table where you can prepare your food before cooking, keep plates for when meals are ready, or store tools and seasonings you’ll need when cooking tasty meals for family and friends.

During cooking, you can use the integrated lid thermometer to check on the internal heat, allowing you to cook your meat and vegetables to your preferred taste. If you need to adjust the temperature, you can utilize the adjustable dampers without lifting the lid, ensuring the accumulated heat remains in the enclosed space.

The backlit LCD timer alerts you when your food is ready to rotate, and because the timer is removable, you can even take it with you when relaxing nearby with a refreshing drink and enjoyable company.

Pros

  • Electronic Touch-N-Go gas ignition system
  • Built-in lid thermometer for easy reading
  • Large workstation for food preparation
  • Charbin storage container for quick access to fuel
  • Precision temperature control for ideal cooking conditions

Cons

  • Propane tank is not included

2. Runner Up - Dyna Glo DGN576DNC-D Premium Charcoal Grill

DGN576DNC-D Premium

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 60.22” x 50.51” x 28.16”
  • Weight: 96 lbs.
  • Heavy-duty grill piece for durability
  • Steel access door

When cooking for a large number of people, perhaps for a family gathering or a party with friends or colleagues, you can use this grill to have all the food ready at the same time. The primary cooking area measures 576 square inches, and is complemented by the secondary grate which measures 240 square inches

In addition to having a large supply of meat ready to serve, there is plenty of space for vegetables, with or without skewers. The cooking grates are made of porcelain-enameled cast-iron that provides maximum heat transfer. This feature helps to ensure food is thoroughly cooked and is the ideal material for searing meat for the perfect finish. 

Although this grill does not have variable cooking levels, you have complete control over the internal temperature by using the adjustable crank to raise and lower the charcoal tray. For slow cooking, set it at the lowest level, or to seal meat that is ready to serve, lift it close to the food for a final blast of heat. For increased temperature control, you can also use the adjustable flue on the stainless steel smokestack.

Because you can cook substantial quantities of food on this grill, you also need a large ash pan, and the high-capacity container that comes included can store a considerable amount of ash before you need to empty it for the next cooking session. This feature is also useful for cleaning because you can lift it out and wipe it down when the ash is cooled down.

Pros

  • Generous 816 square-inch cooking area
  • Porcelain-enameled cast-iron cooking grate
  • Adjustment crank for moving charcoal tray
  • Adjustable flue for added temperature control
  • High-capacity ash pan for easy clean-up

Cons

  • Cooking level is not variable

3. Best Budget - Weber 51040001 Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill

Q1200

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 15.5” x 40.9” x 16.5” 
  • Weight: 26 lbs.
  • 8500 BTUs
  • Removable catch pan

If you’re shopping on a budget, there’s no need to accept a drop in quality. This model has a range of features you would expect to see on more expensive models.

Not everyone needs a large cooking area, and it can also be useful to have a grill that you can put in the car or an RV to take it with you for a day out in nature or to tailgate. This grill may not cook as much food in one session as some more expensive models, but it makes up for it by being portable and having several excellent supporting features. 

If you’re taking your grill on a trip, there may be some accidental bumps and scrapes along the way, especially during loading and unloading. The durable aluminum lid and body can withstand impacts, and the glass-reinforced nylon frame provides an extra layer of protection. While it is compact during transportation, or for storage when not in use, the folding side tables provide extra workspace. 

The straightforward design uses only one stainless steel burner, and you can pick between disposable 14.1 oz. or 16.4 oz. LP cylinders to provide the fuel for cooking. Adding a touch of style to your cooking experience, you can choose one of 6 attractive color schemes. For the ultimate in grilling convenience, this model comes fully-assembled, so you can start using it straight out-of-the-box.

With the incredible array of features that come in a compact unit, this grill provides outstanding value for money.

Pros

  • Glass-reinforced nylon frame
  • Durable aluminum lid and body
  • Folding side tables for increased workspace
  • Comes fully assembled

Cons

  • Relatively small cooking area compared to some rivals

4. Best for Accessibility - Dyna Glo DGN486SNC-D Heavy Duty Stainless Charcoal Grill

DGN486SNC-D

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 55.79” x 28.43” x 50.98”
  • Weight: 84 lbs.
  • 8-inch resin wheels for maneuverability 
  • Uses cast iron and stainless steel materials

With a generous cooking surface area of 686 square inches, you can barbecue an incredible 24 hamburgers simultaneously. The double-walled lid and front firebox ensure that you retain the maximum amount of heat, reducing cooking time and saving on fuel costs. 

Open the cast-iron and steel access door to load in charcoal, and to stoke it when you need more heat. The built-in stainless temperature gauge provides an instant and accurate reading of the internal grill heating level. 

If you need to adjust the temperature, there is a charcoal tray adjustment system that allows you to fine-tune the heat settings. There is also an adjustable flue in the stainless steel smoke stack that adds a further heat control mechanism. 

This exceptional level of control is perfect for when you want to cook meat to the individual preferences of many guests since you can lower and raise the heat quickly and easily.

The 3 hi-gloss porcelain-enameled cast-iron grates provide maximum heat transference, which helps to seal meat and keep the natural juices and flavors within the food. The handy storage basket can also hold a number of useful tools and cooking essentials such as tongs, aprons, seasonings, and oils.

Bringing a modern take to assembly, there is an app that provides straightforward instructions in 3D, which is ideal for simplifying the construction process. Although a protective grill cover is not included, you can purchase one, helping to increase the lifespan of your grill.

Pros

  • Double-walled lid and front firebox
  • 3D interactive assembly instructions available on the included app
  • Easy access to charcoal for stoking
  • 686 total square inches of cooking space
  • Built-in temperature gauge

Cons

  • BBQ cover is not included

Final Verdict

Buying a grill is an investment that can provide many years of enjoyable outdoor cooking experiences. When it comes to high-quality and reliable grills, Weber and Dyna Glo are market leaders and continue to provide innovative designs that improve the BBQing experience.

While there are a number of excellent options, there is one model that stands head-and-shoulders above its rivals. Bringing a blend of accessibility with the in-built Charbin storage container, the ability to cook food to perfection with the easily-adjustable temperature settings, and the large work area that is ideal for preparing food, this model checks all the BBQ boxes.

Convenience is crucial when deciding whether to cook on an outdoor grill or in the kitchen and by providing an easy and instant start-up button, you can enjoy outdoor cooking without hassle after a long day at work or at play. 

Work surface areas beside the grill can save you time, and let you prepare vegetables while the meat is cooking, and this model has a substantial area for food preparation and plate storage. It’s also an ideal place for setting a drink while you relax and chat during cooking.

For the best grill available on the market today, buy the Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill.


Brand Comparisons

Every Weber and Dyna Glo grill is high-quality, produces excellent cooking results, and provides an enjoyable grilling experience. When you’re deciding between them, it can be challenging to narrow down your choices, so it’s useful to consider the features that each manufacturer brings to the market. 

Assembling the Grill

Before you can start cooking, you need to assemble the grill. Although the Weber 51040001 Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill comes fully-assembled, that is only possible because it is a portable unit which is significantly smaller than a unit that is only for at-home use. You need to assemble the larger grills yourself, and although the instructions are straightforward, Dyna Glo has innovated by using modern technology.

After downloading their app, you can view instructions in 3D, which could save you a lot of time and hassle. Being able to see the grill parts in the same format as they are when they come out of the box, makes it easier to connect them to the right components.

Cooking Surface Area

The Dyna Glo DGN576DNC-D Premium charcoal grill offers a generous cooking area of 816 square inches using 2 cooking surfaces. Part of the fun of a party is eating at the same time as other guests, and so this is ideal if you’re catering for a large group.

If you don’t throw many parties, then the 316 square inches of cooking area on the Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill is a better fit. In addition, if you like to BBQ when you’re away on a day out, by choosing the Weber 51040001 Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill you can take the grill with you. The grill space is only 189 square inches, but it could be worth it if you can cook on the beach or at a campsite.

Temperature Control

The Dyna-Glo DGN576DNC-D Premium charcoal grill offers excellent temperature control using the adjustable crank. This lever lowers and raises the charcoal tray, so you can decide how close the coals should be to the food. By using the built-in lid thermometer, you can check the internal temperature, and adjust the height setting of the coals accordingly. 

While the Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill also has an integrated lid thermometer, adjusting the temperature is slightly more difficult. You can control the flow of oxygen to the coals by adjusting the dampers

While the dampers are also easy to use, judging the correct amount of oxygen required is challenging, and you could easily raise the temperature too high or too low. However, you can close the dampers completely to extinguish the coals, which is an excellent feature for cooling the grill down quickly.

Preparation Surface Area

For the ability to prepare the main course and sides simultaneously, the Dyna Glo DGN486SNC-D Heavy Duty Stainless Charcoal Grill provides 2 good-sized side trays. 

Although the Weber Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill is portable, the fold-out side preparation areas also bring enough space to make a full-meal without leaving the grill. This feature is ideal for saving time and helps to keep the conversation going because you won’t need to pop back to the kitchen.