Weber VS KitchenAid Grills Reviews

We hope you love the products we recommend. SeriouslySmoked.com may earn a commission on qualifying purchases from Amazon Associates or other vendors. Read more here.

Last Updated on February 19, 2021

A long-time contributor to SeriouslySmoked, has written widely about the world of barbecue and grilling.

Comparison

Outdoor cookouts are one of the most enjoyable ways to prepare, cook, and share food with friends in your backyard. Grilling provides delicious flavor into your favorite barbeque menu items and cooking over an open flame is one of the more fun ways to do so. 

While there are a number of different kinds of grills that offer their own advantages, gas grills are popular for many, as they provide the functionality, power, and convenience of a grill, without the hassle of dealing with charcoal or pellets

Gas-powered grills can either be connected to the main gas line or a replaceable propane tank, and eliminating the use of charcoal or pellets makes starting, heating, and cleaning your grill very quick, easy, and mess-free

In addition, gas grills can be quite large, letting you cook for a big group of people easily. When it comes to outdoor grills and cooking, Weber and KitchenAid are both brands that offer premier cooking experiences, catered to, and by professional cooks. 

For a high-quality propane-powered grill that you can move around your backyard, the Weber 46502001 Spirit S-315 LP Gas Grill is a great option that you will love.

Brand Overviews

Propane and gas grills are an extremely popular choice for grilling, due to their ease of use and convenient gas source. While many may prefer cooking over charcoal, propane grills can accomplish the same job easier. Weber and KitchenAid Grills are great options for gas grills.


Weber

Weber is a well-known barbeque brand that makes all kinds of grills. It is known for its authentic charcoal grills, so you know that their gas grills are built to cook just as well. 

Modeled after the same high-quality cooking experience, these gas grills bring ease and convenience to outdoor grilling. They require very little set-up time, can be heated up to smoke, grill, or roast, and cleaned up in just moments, making a backyard get-together all fun and no mess. Weber gas grills range from 1-6 burners and offer a number of different features, making these grills versatile and adaptable for any situation.  

If you are looking for a small grill that is easy to move around your backyard or even transport to picnics or tailgating parties, you can find more portable options among the Spirit, Spirit II, and Weber Q series. For larger grills great for cooking for the whole family or your friends, the Genesis II and Summit series may be more what you are looking for.


KitchenAid Grills

KitchenAid is a reputed brand in the kitchen and cooking industries and aims to bring you a fully-functioning outdoor kitchen. The brand’s innovation in gas grills comes from its experience perfecting the art of cooking over the last 100 years

Known for products that deliver mouthwatering results, KitchenAid makes high-quality 2-8 burner propane grills, built-ins, and outdoor kitchen islands. Depending on how big a grill you need or where you will be using it, KitchenAid has a number of options that can suit you.

KitchenAid knows the importance of being able to cook a large amount of food for a lot of people, with its grills providing a lot of cook space and heat options. It also offers unique cooking options such as rotisserie burners, side burners, and flame tamers

KitchenAid has taken the time to make sure it has perfected the way you grill so that your burgers turn out exactly how you like them every time. 

No matter what your outdoor cooking preference and frequency, these Weber and KitchenAid grills provide suitable options to cover a variety of needs.


Weber VS Kamado Grills - 2021 Reviews

Our Top Choice...

Key Features

  • Easy-to-clean porcelain-coated cast-iron grates
  • Distributes even heat. No hot or cold spots.
  • Durable and rust-resistant stainless steel construction
  • Warming rack keeps food ready to serve
  • Grease is funneled into a drip tray

1. Best Overall - Weber 46502001 Spirit S-315 LP Gas Grill

46502001 Spirit S-315

Specifications:

  • 52” x 24” x 45.5”
  • Weighs 124.7 lbs
  • Has 3 burners
  • 3D interactive assembly instructions

While the stylish black and stainless steel finish may be the first aspect that grabs your attention, on further inspection, you’ll be amazed at the incredible range of features. The weatherproof finish is both rust-resistant and corrosion-resistant for a long lifespan. The porcelain-coated cast-iron grates are easy to wipe down and can withstand heating at extreme temperatures. 

By keeping your grill and its components clean, you can ensure it performs at peak efficiency time after time.

The 424 sq. in. of primary cooking surface area provides plenty of room to cook for medium- to large-sized groups, and you can use the integrated warming rack to keep the meat warm after cooking. This feature is ideal when you are preparing sides, vegetables, or other foods to go along with the meat. The warming rack keeps the meat heated without further cooking, so it stays tender and moist.

The special flavorizer cooking grid evenly distributes heat across the cooking chamber, ensuring that each piece of meat is cooked thoroughly. These bars help to reduce the chances of cold spots on the grill that could leave meat undercooked, or hot spots that could cause overcooking.

There are 2 side tables for holding seasonings and sauces, while the handy tool hooks on these shelves are ideal for keeping your essential cooking utensils within reach. For added convenience, any drippings don’t vaporize upon contact with the flavorizer bars, funnel into a disposable drip tray. This feature makes cleaning straightforward and reduces the risk of any flare-ups by keeping the grease away from the burners.

Pros

  • Easy-to-clean porcelain-coated cast-iron grates
  • Durable and rust-resistant stainless steel construction
  • Flavorizer bars distribute heat evenly
  • Warming rack keeps food ready to serve

Cons

  • Door is fragile and can be bent easily

2. Runner Up - KitchenAid 720-0954R Propane Gas Grill

720-0954R

Specifications:

  • 25.59” x 48.81” x 52.36”
  • Weighs 141.1 lbs.
  • Has 4 burners 
  • 696 sq. in. of total cooking space

This grill is ready to use with propane gas, but you can use the included conversion kit to change to natural gas if you prefer. The enormous total cooking power of 55,000 BTUs provides quick and effective heating for fast cooking. 

For slow cooking, you can use the control knobs to lower the temperature. These controls are intuitive, and they’re as easy to use the knobs on your oven.

The advanced continuous electronic ignition system guarantees a quick start every time, and the built-in temperature gauge on the lid provides accurate readings. By knowing the precise temperature in the internal cooking chamber, you can make the required adjustments to ensure you cook your meat through to perfection.

Below the cooking surface, the intelligent design uses angled flame tamers. This feature helps to distribute heat evenly, ensuring there are not any hot or cold spots in the grill. If you are heating up soups, sauces, or marinades, then the integrated side burner can produce 15,000 BTUs of energy. This is ideal for cooking a full meal without having to make extra trips to the kitchen.

For easier cleaning, the handy grill swivel means you can easily wipe down the stainless steel cooking grids. The locking casters hold the grill firmly in place so you can wash the outside surfaces, and lightly dry with a towel.

Pros

  • Provides 55,000 of total BTUs power
  • Dual-energy gas valve allows for easy natural gas conversion
  • Continuous electronic ignition system makes start-up easy
  • Angled flame tamers help to spread heat evenly
  • Built-in temperature gauge for precise cooking

Cons

  • Stainless steel cooking grate is not as durable as porcelain grates
  • Infrared burners make it more difficult to move

3. Best Budget - Weber 46110001 Spirit E-210 Gas Grill | Liquid Propane, 2-Burner

46110001 Spirit E-210

Specifications:

  • 32” x 50” x 63”
  • Weighs 113.8 lbs.
  • Has 2 burners
  • 450 sq. in. of cooking surface

With heavy-duty caster wheels, a porcelain-lined lid, and a porcelain cooking space, the Weber Spirit E-210 is a great option for those who have a small space but still want a well-built grill. Its wheels provide great maneuverability, especially on small balconies or patios

It comes equipped with 6 built-in tool hooks for seamless storage. Because it is designed for small spaces, it comes with 2 folding side tables that give you space for a full grilling experience, but fold down when it’s time to store the grill. 

Ideal for a small balcony and cooking mainly steaks/burgers, this very simple grill has no real bells and whistles. With that being said, it still has a very solid, quality construction

There is a grill cabinet with one painted steel door for easy access. Also, you have access to a grease tray with a catch pan so that cleanup is as simple as possible. The Spirit has a wide temperature range so you can cook at very low temperatures if you so desire. The E-210 is the cheapest and smallest Weber full-sized grill that you can purchase. 

More expensive Weber grills are made from stainless steel but the E-210 is made from enameled steel. Although the manufacturer did this to bring the price down, some customers still recommend this grill over the more expensive S-210 which is made from stainless steel. 

Weber’s compact 2-burner grill is a great choice for people with smaller cooking spaces. You can still get the quality grilling experience that Weber is known for, just in a compact form.

Pros

  • Porcelain-coated cast-iron cooking grates
  • Built-in lid thermometer for precise cooking
  • Electronic crossover ignition system
  • Easy to access grease tray with catch pan
  • Compact and easy to move

Cons

  • Can run either too hot or too cold
  • Some users report issues with igniter

4. Best Built-in Grill - KitchenAid 740-0780 Built-in Propane Gas Grill

740-0780LP

Specifications:

  • 34.2” x 25.7” x 24.5”
  • Weighs 92.3 lbs.
  • Has 4 burners and 1 ceramic rotisserie burner
  • 775 sq. in. of cooking space

The fully stainless steel construction of this KitchenAid grill is extremely durable. It is easy to use and compact, making it a great choice for budget grillers or beginners. It comes with a natural gas conversion kit in case you decided to use natural gas as your fuel source instead of propane gas. 

The KitchenAid 740 has dual energy valves that have natural gas openings which make it quite easy to switch between the 2 different fuel types. 

This grill has a 10-year main burner warranty so you never have to worry about paying out of pocket to replace them any time soon. A unique feature of the KitchenAid 740 is its angled flame tamers that prevent flare-ups, divert heat, and turn drippings into flavor mixtures. 

With its Even-Heat System, you never have to worry about unevenly-cooked meals. This system provides consistent and steady heat throughout the cooking grates. It is equipped with a built-in thermometer for temperature regulation. 

There is no need to assemble anything once you unpackage this KitchenAid grill. Cleaning is a breeze. Most customers report that it is very easy to brush off cooking remains after you are finished. The electronic ignition system ensures that you can light your grill every single time.  

It is cheaper and more compact than most competitor products on the market. Although it is more affordable than most models, it can still compete with more expensive competitor models.

Pros

  • High-quality stainless steel burners
  • Puts out 61,000 BTUs of energy
  • Electronic ignition makes start-up easy
  • Flame tamers distribute heat and vaporize drippings
  • Rotisserie burner allows for added cooking versatility

Cons

  • Internal heat can be hard to control
  • Spark igniters have caused issues

Final Verdict

46502001 Spirit S-315

The Weber 46502001 Spirit S-315 LP Gas Grill is extremely durable and designed for optimal performance. The weatherproof finish features both rust-resistant and corrosion-resistant attributes which will increase the lifespan of your grill. The porcelain-coated cast-iron grates are easy to clean and can stand the test against extreme temperatures. 

This grill has top-of-the-line features, but it is available at an affordable price. The warming rack keeps your food heated while you wait for everything else to finish cooking. Its evenly distributed heat cooks your food consistently and thoroughly without the appearance of hot or cold spots. 

It is available in both natural gas and liquid propane so you can choose the option which best suits your needs. Crafted with efficiency, performance, and durability in mind, this grill is perfect for beginners or those well established with grilling.


Brand Comparisons

The Weber and KitchenAid brands both offer great choices for the outdoor cooking experience. As with any purchase, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of each brand and grill to make sure that you’re investing your hard-earned dollars into an appliance that will be dependable and long-lasting. 

A lot of the decision comes down to personal preference, but there are some significant differences between the brands that should be considered as well. 

Before you plan your next backyard barbecue, be sure to take a look at factors like temperature range, cooking surface area, and warranty.

Temperature Range

The temperature ranges of grills are essential because this feature directly speaks to the versatility of the grill. While most grills and smokers operate at low temperatures, it’s important to remember that the sweet spot for smoking is around 200°F to 225°F, while high-intensity searing needs to get upward of 450°F

If you plan on trying to do both on one appliance, you’ll want to find a grill that has a broad temperature range to accommodate that need.

Some Weber propane or natural gas models offer temperature ranges from as little as 150°F to as high as 600°F, making them one of the most versatile grills on the market today. It’s possible to smoke, bake, braise, or roast on these grills with ease and then end the process by cranking up the heat to create those spectacular sear marks that every pitmaster seeks. You can still smoke with natural gas and propane, it just takes a little bit of DIY mixed in with trial-and-error.

Cooking Surface Area

Cooking surface area preferences depend on what you’re planning to cook, how you’re planning on cooking it, and how many people you’re planning on cooking for. If you have a small family, opt for a grill that has less cooking space and a smaller footprint so you don’t have to worry about your appliance taking up too much space in your backyard. 

If you plan on inviting the entire neighborhood over for a pool party or cookout regularly, invest in a grill that has a lot of cooking space so that you never have to worry about running out of food or delays in dishing out your courses.

Warranty

Warranties are one of the most important things to consider when buying any appliance, not just a grill. Warranties inform the consumer that the company is willing to stand by any product it places on the market by claiming it to be superior to others. 

Make sure your gas grill not only comes with a warranty but that it specifically covers the burners for an extended period. This is because gas burners are usually the one thing that needs to be replaced on a gas grill before anything else.

Both Weber and KitchenAid offer a 10-year limited warranty which is perfect for durability and longevity. KitchenAid also offers a 3-year warranty on grates and a 1-year warranty on all other components, which is ideal. Weber offers a 2-year warranty on parts like ignition switches.