Weber VS Napoleon Grills Reviews

We hope you love the products we recommend. SeriouslySmoked.com may earn a commission on qualifying purchases from Amazon Associates or other vendors. Read more here.

Last Updated on February 19, 2021

A long-time contributor to SeriouslySmoked, has written widely about the world of barbecue and grilling.

Comparison

When choosing a new grill, it’s essential to check out the range of Weber and Napoleon grills. As industry leaders in the outdoor cooking world for many years, they continue to design and manufacture some of the most innovative grills available on the market.  

Although you can pick the model that has the most features, this may not be the best way to choose between the brands. You may have unique preferences that mean a large grilling area is a necessity, or if you cook often, then a quick ignition system and easy cleanup are essential. 

Reliability is always a key factor, and you’ll want to know that your grill provides even and consistent heat distribution for every cooking session. Durability is also crucial, and there are many grills made of materials that are both rust- and corrosion-resistant. This can be especially important if you keep your grill outdoors.

Your budget may also determine which grill is most suitable for you, and fortunately, there are many superb grills at every price point. With the range of color choices and designs, you can even consider the style you prefer.

While there are many excellent available options, for the best grill on the market, consider the Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill.

Brand Overviews

The grilling market has several excellent manufacturers who can supply reliable grills at reasonable prices. However, Weber and Napoleon can claim to be at the forefront of the outdoor cooking industry, and they have built up loyal customer bases over many decades.

Their experience and ability to integrate modern designs and materials into their grills make these brands 2 of the most discussed at cookouts around the globe.

Weber

It was in 1953 that George Stephen, Weber’s founder, made his first kettle grill. George believed that a round cooking bowl with a lid over the top could make a top-quality grill. 

Since then, Weber has diversified its product range to include cooking utensils, fuel, drip pans, gloves and aprons, and just about every outdoor grilling accessory you could need. 

However, the focus remains on its grills. Weber understands that value for money is important, and it constructs its grills using durable materials that can last for many years. 

While Weber produces high-end models that have luxury features that can meet any grilling need, grills at the lower end of the price range also come with components that improve the outdoor cooking experience. 

Some features that are familiar to Weber enthusiasts include hinged grates, built-in lid thermometers, intelligent design for increased preparation areas, and precision temperature control systems. While the kettle design is its most recognizable style, Weber also has a range of other grills that produce outstanding results at every cook-out.

When buying a grill, checking out the Weber range should be a priority.


Napoleon

The first line of Napoleon grills went on sale in 1981, and over the next 4 decades, Napoleon has gone on to become one of the leading brands throughout Canada and North America

While the brand has an all-around knowledge of heating, also producing fireplaces and furnaces, it is perhaps best known for its extensive and high-quality range of outdoor grills. 

Napoleon produces grills that have an enormous cooking area and are suitable for commercial environments, right down to small grills that are ideal for use by a single grillmaster. With a fantastic range of features such as multiple cooking zones, flame-throwing ignitions, and even integrated rotisserie burners, Napoleon is a firm favorite among grilling enthusiasts. Napoleon also has many grills that are affordable on a budget and come with exceptional features.

Before purchasing an outdoor grill, it’s essential to consider the wide range of Napoleon grills.


Weber VS Napoleon Grills - 2021 Reviews

Our Top Choice...

Key Features

  • Instant start gas ignition system
  • Built-in lid thermometer for accurate readings
  • Integrated fuel storage container
  • Long table included for food preparation
  • Fine-tune the temperature for fast or slow cooking
  • Choose from black, green, and copper color schemes
  • Straightforward One-Touch cleaning system for cleanup

1. Best Overall - Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill

Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 43.5″ x 48″ x 30″ 
  • Weight: 91 lbs.
  • Choose from black, green, and copper color schemes
  • Straightforward One-Touch cleaning system for cleanup

The instant start electronic Touch-N-Go ignition system on this model guarantees to light your grill every time. Once lit, you can add more charcoal from the integrated Charbin storage bin. You can say goodbye to carrying heavy bags of charcoal from your garage to your grill, and the mess that comes with it. 

The built-in lid thermometer provides you with real-time, accurate readings of the heat level in the cooking chamber. If the temperature is too low, open the dampers wider to increase the airflow into the fuel. If it’s too high, slightly close the dampers and less oxygen reaches the fuel, quickly reducing the heat.

You can also choose between direct and indirect heating by adjusting the charcoal placement on the grill. This feature is ideal for when you like to vary between slow and fast cooking. 

When you’ve chosen your desired temperature, set the removable LED timer, and take it with you while you relax around the table with friends. The timer provides a helpful reminder when you need to turn the meat, so you don’t have to worry about overcooking.

The long table preparation area is ideal for laying out plates, and the durable surface can withstand hot temperatures without tarnishing. There is also plenty of room for preparing vegetables and other sides to go along with the main course. 

The streamlined design makes this model a feature in your yard as well as a grill.

Pros

  • Instant start gas ignition system
  • Built-in lid thermometer for accurate readings
  • Integrated fuel storage container
  • Long table included for food preparation
  • Fine-tune the temperature for fast or slow cooking

Cons

  • Propane tank for ignition system comes separately

2. Runner Up - Napoleon PRO605CSS Professional Charcoal Grill

PRO605CSS Professional Charcoal Grill

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 49.25” x 24.75” x 67.5”
  • Weight: 232 lbs.
  • Stainless steel construction
  • Comes with stainless steel grill head fully assembled

If you plan on throwing a party or regularly cook for large gatherings, you’ll love the 605 sq. in. of primary cooking area, and the 249 sq. in. of secondary cooking area on this model. Incredibly, together they can accommodate 37 4-inch hamburgers. The easy-access fronting load door allows you to add charcoal without having to lift the lid. 

When the coals have heated up, use the adjustable charcoal bed to set the charcoal height at one of 6 pre-set levels. For a slow cook, set the bed at the lowest level, and then raise it close to the meat for searing. 

The cast-iron cooking grates provide even heat distribution and create restaurant-grade sear marks for a beautiful finish, and built with stainless steel one of the best materials up to date. If you like a smoky grill flavor on your meat, add flavored wood chips to your lit charcoal, and let the aromas infuse into your food. 

This model also comes with a rear rotisserie burner so you can perfectly cook chicken, ham, and other meats. Once they’re on, you only need to keep the charcoal at the preferred level and let the rotisserie burner do the rest of the work.

The integrated tool hooks mean you can have all your cooking utensils within reach, and the removable ash and drip pans make cleaning up a straightforward task. For your convenience, Napoleon has assembly and maintenance videos on their website. You can be ready to cook and care for your grill almost as soon as it arrives at your door.

Pros

  • Height-adjustable charcoal bed
  • Easy access front load door
  • Integrated tool hooks
  • Total cooking area of 854 sq. in.
  • Ash and drip pan for easy cleaning

Cons

  • Heavier than many rival grills

3. Best Budget - Weber 51040001 Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill

Q1200

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 15.5” x 40.9” x 16.5” 
  • Weight: 26 lbs.
  • Can provide up to 8500 BTUs
  • Good-sized ash catcher

While there are luxury grills that have a high price tag, there is no need to compromise on quality if you are shopping on a budget. This beautiful, portable model from Weber has many features you would expect to find on more expensive grills. Providing excellent value for money, the durable aluminum lid and body are weather-resistant. 

They are also strong and can withstand the rigors of going camping or tailgating when there can be accidental drops and scrapes. The porcelain-enameled cast-iron cooking grates are corrosion- and rust-resistant. 

These grids provide excellent heat retention, and are superb for searing meat. This feature helps to stop juices and the smoky grill flavors from escaping, giving you melt-in-your-mouth, tasty meat.

Because this grill is portable, it has handy side carry handles, and it also sits off the ground on the built-in legs. These legs provide stability so your grill can sit on a flat level, and also keeps it away from the ground to avoid the chances of accidental scorching of the grass.

There is precision temperature control using the control knob, so you can fine-tune the heat level to your preference. The 2-fold outside tables provide room to keep your cooking utensils, seasonings, and your drink, and you can fold them away after use for easy storage. 

Although the cooking area may not suit those cooking for large groups, there is plenty of space on the 189 sq. in. grill to hold several burgers, pieces of chicken, and sauces.

Pros

  • Robust nylon frame for durability
  • Weather-resistant aluminum for increased lifespan
  • Built-in lid thermometer
  • Handy fold away side tables
  • Precision temperature control

Cons

  • Cooking area may be too small for some customers

4. Best Convenience - Napoleon TQ285XBL1 Propane Gas Grill

TQ285XBL1 Propane Gas Grill

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 20.25” x 44.25” x 38.75”
  • Weight: 53.9 lbs.
  • Material: Cast-iron
  • 12,000 BTU capacity

If you like to cook at a grill while standing up, but also want it to be portable, this model could be the right choice for you. While most portable grills sit just off the ground, this can be uncomfortable for some. 

The folding legs on this grill make it compact and easy to carry when contracted, but when extended they provide you with a comfortable cooking height. The intelligently-designed handle also makes it possible to carry this grill with one hand, which is ideal if you are unpacking a lot of equipment at a campsite. The attached wheels make it easy to move the grill if you are trying to stay in the sunny parts of the site.

The ignition system on this grill is the same as Napoleon uses for their high-end grills, and so you can rely on it to light. While it is compatible for use with 1 lb. propane tanks, you can use the included conversion kit to attach 20 lb. tanks. 

This feature is ideal if you are away for an extended time, or cooking for a large group. There is no need to make unnecessary trips to the store to refill the gas tank.

The dual-burners allow you to have a versatile 2-zone cooking system. Utilize these zones to put out food to your guests in stages, or to cook meats and sides at the same time.

Pros

  • Electric power source
  • 285 sq. in. grilling area
  • Conversion kit to attach larger propane tanks
  • Reliable flame throwing ignition
  • 2 cooking zone system

Cons

  • Not as sturdy as some rival grills

Final Verdict

Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill

Outdoor cooking is a social event as much as it is about making a meal. By investing in a Weber or Napoleon model, you can be confident you’re buying a grill that can give you many years of enjoyable cooking experiences. 

Although there are individual reasons you may prefer one grill over another, there is one grill that currently stands head-and-shoulders above its rivals. 

The electronic Touch-N-Go ignition system makes lighting your grill a hassle-free experience, and the ability to use direct or indirect heat allows flexibility when cooking.  The integrated Charbin storage container for the fuel helps to save time and effort, while the LED removable timer allows you to mix with friends without worrying about forgetting to turn the meat.

The single long workspace gives your plenty of room for preparing side dishes and vegetables, and the easy-wipe surface means you can keep it clean and hygienic. The One-Touch cleaning system and the large ash catcher tray make cleaning up after cooking a straightforward task. 

Weber has used the highest-quality materials when building this grill, so you can rely on it to cook great tasting meat for years to come. For the best grill on the market, buy the Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill.


Brand Comparisons

Choosing between a Weber and a Napoleon grill can be a challenging task. Both brands have legendary status, and each model is built using high-quality materials, and uses industry-leading designs. 

As most outdoor grillers have individual preferences regarding grill features and style, it’s often 1 or 2 specific characteristics that can help to make a final decision.

Cooking Surface Area

If you cook for a small household, only yourself, or like to take your grill away when camping, a smaller cooking surface area is a good choice. The Weber 51040001 Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill is compact and ideal for cooking for small groups. 

If the 189 sq. in. of cooking surface area is too small, the Napoleon TQ285XBL1 Propane Gas Grill is also portable, but has a slightly large cooking surface area of 285 sq. in. 

However, if you want to cook for large numbers of people, then there is only one choice. Coming with an enormous grilling area of 854 sq. in., the Napoleon PRO605CSS Professional Charcoal Grill is the clear winner.

Cooking Temperature

Control over the cooking temperature is vital when grilling. If the heat level is too high, then meat may not cook all the way through and it also loses its moisture. If the temperature is too low, then it could take a long time for the meat to cook. 

The 2-zone cooking of the Napoleon TQ285XBL1 Propane Gas Grill provides a high degree of control, and the temperature changes quickly after you turn the heat-adjustment knob. 

Although the Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill uses dampers to control the airflow, and therefore requires some judgment, it is an excellent way to introduce more oxygen to the charcoal

If you feel the meat is about to overcook, closing the dampers stops air from entering the cooking chamber. While it may take some getting used to, this is an intuitive and fun way to control the cooking temperature on your grill.

Grilling Preparation Area

When guests are in the backyard having a good time, you don’t want to be stuck in the kitchen preparing the meal. The Napoleon PRO605CSS Professional Charcoal Grill provides substantial side trays that allow you to keep many of your cooking essentials handy. 

However, Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill uses one long side table, rather than two smaller ones. This gives you the advantage of having everything on the same side of the grill. 

You can marinate your meats, chop your vegetables, and have all your seasonings beside each other. While this is convenient, it also means you can stand in one place while preparing the meal, enjoying the conversation with your guests.

Stylish Design

Although it may not be the main reason you buy a grill, the design can be important. The grill is a feature in your backyard, and you want it to look great when having people over for a cookout. 

The Weber 51040001 Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill has a sleek design and a choice of 6 attractive color schemes, so it can match with the furniture you already own. However, in terms of being a talking point as well as an exceptional grill, the Weber 15501001 Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill is slimline, comes in 3 stylish colors, and looks great in any environment.