Z Grills vs Pit Boss Reviews

We hope you love the products we recommend. SeriouslySmoked.com may earn a commission on qualifying purchases from Amazon Associates or other vendors. Read more here.

Last Updated on January 20, 2021

Our Top Choice...

Key Features

  • 440 sq. in. of porcelain coated steel cooking space w/ temperatures ranging from 180 to 500F
  • 5 lbs. hopper with a safety grid, bottle opener, and combination side shelf and serving tray and tool hooks
  • Innovative flame broiler for tasty results
  • Dial-In digital temperature control with LED read-out

Z Grills VS Pit Boss

When choosing a grill, it is essential to consider the fantastic ranges offered by Z Grill and Pit Boss. As 2 of the leading names in the outdoor cooking industry for several decades, they have an enviable reputation among their contemporaries. 

Both brands provide cutting-edge models that produce fantastic grilling results time after time. Although there is a grill that meets just about every cooking requirement, there are others that come with many additional outstanding features.

Instant start ignition systems, large cooking surface areas, digital temperature controls, and integrated thermometers are excellent features that are present on many grills.

If you like to cook food regularly, you may value a grill that heats up quickly. However, if you like to relax with a drink and slow cook your food for hours, then an indirect heating system is a good choice. Having a grill just for your backyard may be suitable, or perhaps you’d like to take it with you on camping trips as well. Whatever your preference, there is a Z Grill and Pit Boss grill that can meet your unique needs. 

If you’re ready to invest in the best grill on the market, then buy the Pit Boss 72440-PB440D LGrill 440 Deluxe Wood Pellet Grill.

Brand Overviews

Z Grill and Pit Boss are legendary for their grills that provide consistently high-quality cooking results. While each varies in its approach to the design and features on their grills, both brands have loyal followings among the outdoor cooking community.

These 2 grilling giants have remained ahead of their rivals by using the latest techniques and learning from customer feedback, to ensure their next grill is better than their last. 

Before looking at any other supplier, you should check out Z Grill and Pit Boss.

Z Grill

Z Grill prides itself on being the originator of wood pellet grills. Z Grill understands that some grillers value the convenience of gas over charcoal, but that many customers feel that gas doesn’t come with the same flavor as a charcoal grill. The brand’s answer lies in the wood pellet grill.

By using a straightforward dial system to turn the grill on, and an auger to feed the pellets into the firepot where they ignite, Z Grill claims this is just as easy as using a gas grill. However, the taste then comes from the wood pellets, infusing food with a smoky grill flavor that you’d associate with a charcoal grill. 

Z Grill has integrated modern technology into its grills, with the intention of making grilling as easy as possible. It aims to let you start your grill, add your food, and then allow you to relax while the grill does the cooking. 

By automating tasks such as adding fuel and regulating the temperature in the cooking chamber, this manufacturer provides one of the most convenient grills on the market.

When buying a grill that could save you time and money, it’s essential that you consider the range from Z Grill.


Pit Boss

Dan Thiessen and his sons, Jeff and Jordan, founded Pit Boss in 1999. Since then, the company has become a firm favorite with many grillmasters who value craftsmanship and quality. Pit Boss makes grills that you can take with you to a campsite or a tailgate party, as well as grills that wouldn’t look out-of-place in a restaurant.

Pit Boss strives to provide better grills than its rivals at a more affordable price. The size of its ever-growing loyal customer base suggests it is meeting its goals. Pit Boss also loves to be involved in the outdoor cooking community, and is proud to make its own contribution to a better grilling experience.

When choosing a new grill, Pit Boss should be at the top of your list.


Z Grill vs Pit Boss Grills Grills Reviews

1. Best Overall - Pit Boss 72440-PB440D LGrill 440 Deluxe Wood Pellet Grill

72440-PB440D LGrill 440 Deluxe Wood Pellet Grill
Check Price on BBQGuys

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 43.75” x 50.75” x 24”
  • Weight: 73 lbs.
  • Integrated bottle opener
  • Stylish black and copper finish

The instant start electronic ignition system combines with a powerful fan that directs airflow, creating a hot flame that is ideal for convection cooking. The innovative flame broiler is capable of direct and indirect heating, allowing you to cook meat to your preferred taste. 

If you need to heat up food quickly, use direct heating to cook meat over the flame. This method is also ideal for searing meats, keeping the tasty juices inside and keeping your meat moist. 

If you’re in the mood for a slow cookout, use the indirect heating system to allow the internal heat to gently warm the meat until it is cooked through to perfection. This technique is best for allowing the flavors from the grill to slowly infuse with the meat, producing tender fare that is full of appetizing grilling smells and juices in every bite.

The enormous cooking surface area of 465 sq. in. is perfect when you are cooking for large groups because it can accommodate up to 20 burgers. You can also be confident that every piece of meat is full of flavor, since Pit Boss pellets are made of 100% hardwood. There are no additives or chemicals that could affect the flavor. This feature is crucial because it is challenging to maintain a consistent flavor when cooking for so many people. 

This grill is made of heavy-duty 16-gauge steel, so it is both rust- and corrosion-resistant. Although it’s best to cover it when not in use, it can withstand the elements if you forget on occasion.

Pros

Electric ignition system
Large-capacity cooking surface area
Innovative flame broiler for tasty results
Porcelain-coated cast iron cooking grids
Heavy-duty steel construction

Cons

At the higher end of the price range

2. Runner Up - Z Grills ZPG-450A 2020 Upgrade Wood Pellet Grill

ZPG-450A 2020 Upgrade Wood Pellet Grill & Smoker
Check Price on Amazon

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 45” x 28” x 49”
  • Weight: 84 lbs.
  • Push-button start
  • Up to 25,000 BTUs

This incredibly versatile grill can cook in 6 different styles. You can use it to grill, smoke, braise, roast, bake, and BBQ. It’s possible to cook appetizers, entrees, and even desserts on this grill, providing you with all the convenience of a full kitchen, but on the single outdoor grill.

There is a digital automatic temperature control feature that allows you to choose your preferred cooking heat level. There is no need to check on the temperature. The intelligent system monitors the heat in the cooking chamber, and adjusts the amount of fuel accordingly. 

If the temperature drops below the desired level, the automatic pellet feed control system adds just the right amount of pellets to raise the heat level. This feature allows you to relax, sit around your table, and enjoy conversation with friends. The temperature control system is so accurate, it keeps the heat level within 10° on either side of the set heating level.

While this is a user-friendly way to cook your meal, it is also environmentally-friendly and cost-effective. Using 10 lbs. of wood pellets, you can cook for approximately 10 hours. This works out considerably cheaper than gas and charcoal grills. In addition, the less fuel you use, the kinder it is to the environment.

The caster wheels allow you to relocate the grill wherever it is most comfortable and convenient for you.

Pros

Capable of 6 different cooking styles
Digital temperature control
Automatic pellet feed control system
Caster wheels for easy transportation
Efficient cooking system compared to other fuels

Cons

Only works with wood pellets

3. Best Budget - Pit Boss Grills 75275 Stainless Steel Two-Burner Portable Grill

75275
Check Price on Pit Boss

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 23” x 19.5” x 16”
  • Weight: 27 lbs.
  • 38 in. connection hose for LP gas
  • 1-year limited warranty

Shopping for a grill on a budget doesn’t mean you have to settle for a drop in quality. This portable model from Pit Boss comes with a range of great features, and it’s also suitable for use in your backyard or when away on a trip.

The durable stainless steel body and lid construction is robust, and ideal for cooking when camping or tailgating. This grill can withstand the accidental bumps and scrapes that can occur when loading and unloading it. The compact design also means it doesn’t take up much space, during travel and when in use. 

There is a latching hood that ensures the lid stays closed when you’re carrying it, and the folding legs provide a stable cooking platform when you reach your destination. 

Despite the neat design, this grill has a generous cooking surface area of 276 sq. in., which is enough to cook around 11 burgers simultaneously. It comes with 2 10,000 BTU burners that provide plenty of power and control over the cooking zones, and the stainless steel cooking grid transfers heat effectively. This feature is ideal for ensuring there are no cold spots when cooking, and for searing the meat when you’re almost ready to serve. 

To ensure the temperature is steady throughout, you can use the built-in dome thermometer for accurate, real-time readings. If you need to use more fuel, this model is compatible with 20 lb. LP tanks, ensuring you can cook for many hours without needing a refill.

Pros

Compact design for portability
Durable stainless steel construction
Integrated dome thermometer
Works with 20 lb. cylinder
276 sq. in. cooking area

Cons

Not as aesthetically-pleasing as some rival grills

4. Best Convenience - Z Grills ZPG-700D Wood Pellet Grill Smoker

2020 PREMIUM UPDATE PELLET SMOKER
Check Price on Amazon

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 51.2” x 22.5” x 48.4”
  • Weight: 112 lbs.
  • Fuelled by hardwood pellets
  • 3-year warranty

When setting your grill up, it’s essential the hopper capacity is large enough to accommodate the right amount of wood pellets. If it doesn’t hold enough, then it could run out while you’re not beside the grill, allowing the temperature to cool and meat to undercook. This 700d model has a generous 20 lb. hopper capacity, so you can relax knowing it holds enough fuel for up to 5 whole chickens. 

The size of the hopper is related to the cooking surface area, which has a size of 513 sq. in., and an additional 187 sq. in. surface area on the warming rack. When you are having a party or hosting a large gathering, sitting down and eating together is part of the fun. As meat becomes ready to serve, you can set it on the warming rack while you cook the remainder of the food for your guests. 

Allowing the meat to sit on top of the warming rack also provides further opportunity for the smoky flavors from the wood pellets to mix with the meat and give it that authentic grilling flavor.

You can use the digital control board to set the temperature anywhere between 180°F up to 450°F. This feature is ideal for slow-cooking meat, and then turning it up towards the end to sear in the juices. 

When cooking meat, hot grease can run off and gather on the bottom of the grill. This can be challenging to clean, and require a lot of scrubbing. However, this model eliminates that problem through the integrated spigot that drains grease into a cup.

Pros

20 lb. hopper capacity
Superior searing ability
Grease bucket holder
Grill area suitable for cooking for large groups
Provides savory wood-fire taste

Cons

Does not have an ash clean-out system

5. Best Capacity - Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate 4-in-1 LP Gas, Charcoal

Memphis Ultimate 4-in-1 LP Gas
Check Price on Pit Boss

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 48.5” x 30” x 23” 
  • Weight: 141 lbs.
  • 1500-watt electric smoker element
  • Easy to transport on 4 casters

With a total grilling area of 1327 sq. in. and a total smoker area of 840 sq.in., out of the other models, this grill can cook for the largest of parties. There are 3 stainless steel burners that produce a combined 36,000 BTUs. The porcelain-coated cast iron cooking grids and warming racks are excellent for providing heat transference, and you can even adjust the charcoal grate. 

Temperature control is crucial when grilling, and the ability to raise and lower the charcoal bed, gives you precision control over the heat level. For further heat adjustment, you can use the integrated dampers to control the flow of air to the charcoal. 

The more oxygen you allow into the cooking chamber, the hotter it becomes. This is also effective as a safety feature, because when you’re finished cooking, you can fully close the dampers and the charcoal extinguishes rapidly. You can check the coals are cool and safe before heading to bed.

This model also provides you with considerable flexibility when cooking. You can use it as a grill, smoker, liquid gas grill, or an infrared searing burner. No matter which way your guests prefer their meat, this grill can do it all.

Since this is a large grill, it is likely to be a feature in your backyard. The stylish black and stainless steel finish, and the sleek design, means that it looks fantastic on the patio. This is ideal for the serious outdoor grilling enthusiast.

Pros

Porcelain-coated warming racks
Adjustable charcoal grate and dampers
Total cooking area of 2,167 sq. in.
Suitable for 4 different cooking styles
Stylish black and stainless steel finish

Cons

May be larger than many grillers need

6. Best Durability - Z Grills ZPG-6002E 2020 New Model Wood Pellet Grill

ZPG-6002E
Check Price on Amazon

Specifications:

  • Dimensions: 46” x 22” x 46” 
  • Weight: 88.8 lbs.
  • All-terrain wheels
  • Shutdown recycle mode

Because of the push-button ignition and integrated temperature control system, there is no need for lighter fluid when lighting this grill. Use the LED readout to view the temperature in the cooking chamber, and use the digital control to adjust it to your preferred setting. Because the heat level responds instantly to your instructions, you can easily avoid overcooking meat that is already on the grill.

The ZPG-6002E is similar to the ZPG-7002E which you can braise, bake, and smoke, among other cooking styles on the grill, it also offers a superior searing ability. You can turn the temperature up to maximum setting, open the door to allow the maximum amount of oxygen to enter the chamber, and the heat level can rise as high as 1000°F. Because this grill uses a fan-forced convection heating system, there is no need for a rotisserie, helping to save space. 

There is a built-in foldable working shelf, which is ideal for storing your cooking utensils, seasonings, marinades, and also holding your drink while you cook. Although you may occasionally have to refill the 10 lb. capacity hopper if you’re cooking for a large group, the automatic pellet feeding system ensures you can relax, even when your meat is cooking. 

The outside of the grill is made of durable materials that are weather-resistant and easy to wipe down after use. With proper care, this unit can provide many years of excellent cooking service. Internally, the heavy-duty porcelain-coated cast-iron grates are robust and can withstand extreme heat even during extended cookouts.

If you cook in climates where the weather can be extreme or changeable, this is a solid choice.

Pros

Precision temperature control
Foldable working shelf
Made of rust-proof materials
No need for starter fluid
LED temperature readout

Cons

Relatively small hopper capacity of only 1o lbs.

Final Verdict

72440-PB440D LGrill 440 Deluxe Wood Pellet Grill
Check Price on BBQGuys

Although both these trusted and reliable brands have excellent models throughout their impressive product ranges, there is one that stands above its rivals. 

Bringing the convenience of an electric quick-start ignition system, an innovative flame broiler for flavorful cooking results, and using the best in high-quality materials that are built to last, Pit Boss has created an exceptional grill. 

Adding in the incredible versatility, and coming at the affordable price-points that Pit Boss is famous for, it is a great choice for the discerning griller.

For the best available grill on today’s market, the PIT BOSS 72440-PB440D LGrill 440 Deluxe Wood Pellet Grill is the perfect choice.


Brand Comparisons

Every Z Grill and Pit Boss grill is efficient, reliable, durable, and provides excellent value for money. It can be challenging to pick between the brands as well as the models.

However, each outdoor cooking enthusiast has their own preferences. Where one person may prefer a large grill, others may value portability. For some grill masters, perhaps a quick-start system is more important than a height-adjustable charcoal bed.

Fortunately, there is a top notch Z Grill and a Pit Boss grill that can meet just about every requirement.

Cooking Temperature

Temperature control is the key to a good grill. The Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate 4-in-1 LP Gas grill provides one of the most enjoyable ways to adjust the temperature. If you want to raise or lower the heat level in the cooking chamber, open or close the integrated dampers accordingly

While this technique can be challenging to master, as letting too much or too little oxygen through to the coals can have an adverse effect on the cooking temperature, this method has an authentic feel. It is not an exact science, but you can get great satisfaction from eating perfectly-cooked meat that is a product of your accurate judgement.

However, for incredible control and convenience, the Z Grills ZPG-450A 2020 Upgrade Wood Pellet Grill is hard to beat. You can use the digital control setup to choose your preferred heat setting, and then leave the grill, safe in the knowledge that the temperature control system is monitoring the cooking chamber. 

Should the temperature begin to drop, the automatic feeding system adds more wood pellets to the chamber, increasing the temperature back to the required setting. By keeping the cooking chamber at a steady temperature, this grill prepares meat all the way through every time.

We also looked into other grill brands to see how they will compare with Z Grills and Pit Boss. We also compared it with Traeger. We found that Traeger provides a modern solution to monitoring and controlling the grill temperature and hopper via smartphone integration. Further explanation on this on our comparison of Pit Boss vs Traeger guide.

Cooking Surface Area

If you don’t need a substantial cooking area, or you like to take your grill with you when camping, then the Pit Boss Grills 75275 Stainless Steel Two-Burner Portable Grill is ideal. While this is a considerably smaller cooking surface area than many of its rivals, it can still accommodate over 10 burgers at one time, making it adequate for most needs. 

If you cook for large groups of people, there are a number of great options. However, the Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate 4-in-1 LP Gas is considerably more spacious than most grills, and would even be suitable for cooking in a commercial environment. This feature is perfect if you need to have a large amount of food ready at the same time.

Stylish Design

The Z Grills ZPG-6002E 2020 New Model Wood Pellet Grill is beautifully crafted and comes in 2 attractive color schemes. It is a stunning addition to any backyard, and the slimline design means it does not take up a large amount of space. 

However, for a grill that draws admiring glances and is a conversation-starter among visiting guests, the Pit Boss 72440-PB440D LGrill 440 Deluxe Wood Pellet Grill is an outstanding choice. 

The demure color scheme and clean finish allow it to fit seamlessly into any natural setting.